Select committee: Defence Committee
Conclusion 10
Fourth Report - Operation Isotrope: the use of the military to counter migrant crossings
Published 11 Mar 2022
Paragraph 79
Addressed to Ministry of Defence
Defence Committee Operation Isotrope: the use of the military to counter migrant crossings All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Conclusion (the committee's words)
Operation Isotrope’s potential to cause reputational damage to the Royal Navy (and even UK Defence as a whole) is significant. That risk comes from a number of areas: those who believe that this is not a defence task (but rather ought to be carried out by civil authorities); those who believe that the Royal Navy ought to have other, more pressing priorities; and those who believe that the Royal Navy is ineffective in the role, instead becoming a ‘taxi service’ for those crossing the Channel. This reputational damage could likely be countered by clear messaging of what the expectations are upon Royal Navy assets in the Channel and cross-Government agreement of the strategic objective of the operation. However, we have not seen any evidence that that will happen.
From: Defence Committee, Fourth Report - Operation Isotrope: the use of the military to counter migrant crossings (HC 1069), paragraph 79, 11 March 2022
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 19 May 2022 (deadline 11 May 2022).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The government's response sets out military primacy for the Channel response as one element of wider immigration reform, notes some of the Committee's conclusions, and disagrees with others, including on the impact on naval resources.
- On the call for a published handover date, it "notes the Committee's conclusions" and says current planning is for Defence to retain primacy until January 2023, when the "operational requirement and financing arrangements will be reviewed".
- It "disagrees" with the Committee on the deployment of "scarce" naval resources, stating that Operation ISOTROPE "has no impact on the availability of Destroyers, Frigates or Batch 2 OPVs" for deployment overseas or in homeland defence.
- On funding, it states that a £50 million package has been agreed between the Treasury, Home Office and MOD to deliver military primacy until early 2023, when "the requirement and resourcing will be reviewed".
- On British shipbuilding, it "notes the Committee's recommendation" and says the National Shipbuilding Office "will seek to maximise UK content wherever possible".