Recommendation 2

DHSC has failed in one of its most basic duties by keeping no proper record to justify its final selection of schemes for the programme. DHSC and NHS England officials carried out an assessment exercise which recommended 20 schemes for inclusion in the Health Infrastructure Plan (HIP), a 2019 programme that became the main basis for selecting schemes for NHP. In finalising the schemes for announcement, DHSC removed seven of the 20 schemes from the shortlist for HIP and added another 14 that had not been recommended. DHSC told us it was satisfied that those decisions were made on an appropriate basis, but it admitted that no documentation whatsoever existed to explain the decisions. We are troubled that a gap like this can occur regarding such an important investment, particularly since at least some of the seven excluded schemes are known to have an urgent need for major investment or rebuilding. This Committee has previously expressed concern about a lack of evidence to justify scheme selection, and a lack of transparency in selection processes, for the Towns Fund in 2020 and for levelling-up funding in