Source · Select Committees · Public Accounts Committee

Recommendation 15

15

Private leaseholders’ emotional strain has been compounded by rising costs passed on to them by...

Conclusion
Private leaseholders’ emotional strain has been compounded by rising costs passed on to them by their building owners. These costs are often as a result of interim fire safety measures. The Department estimated a common interim measure, waking watches (overnight patrols to evacuate residents in case of fire), to range between £12,000 and £45,000 per week per building depending on the number of individuals and hours covered.45 We received written evidence confidentially for a block where the reserves built up by the leaseholders over 20 years were exhausted in around three months as a result of waking watch costs. The Department told us that building owners “would—or should—consult their leaseholders and explain to them what costs are being put in place and what they are being charged”.46 In response to the concerns we raised about such costs, the Department told us that it is not collecting information on waking watch costs. It told us that it is working with the National Fire Chiefs Council to update their guidance on interim measures, which includes promoting more cost-effective measures to ensure that private leaseholders are more informed consumers.47 We understand the government plans to publish data on the costs of waking watch to ensure greater transparency, which we welcome.48 However, as the Department accepts, these are temporary measures which should never have become permanent fixtures.49
Government Response Not Addressed
HM Government Not Addressed
4.3 However, understandably, many leaseholders are anxious about costs from interim measures, such as waking watch (overnight patrols to evacuate residents in case of fire). The department has been investigating steps to reduce waking watch costs. In October 2020, the department published data on these so there is transparency and cost comparisons can be clearly made. Additionally, the National Fire Chiefs Council has published updated guidance for buildings where ‘stay put’ advice has been suspended, emphasising these are short-term measures and encouraging greater use of more cost-effective measures such as alarm systems, to reduce dependency on waking watch wherever possible.