Select Committee · Public Accounts Committee

AEA Technology Pension Case

Status: Closed Opened: 20 Jan 2023 Closed: 24 Sep 2023 3 recommendations 17 conclusions 2 reports

Following its work on the British Steel Pension Scheme , the Committee will question Government Actuary Martin Clarke and Karl Banister, Director of Operations, Legal and Clinical, from the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman on the Atomic Energy Agency Technology pension case. This inquiry is based on an ongoing NAO investigation which will set out …

Clear

Reports

2 reports
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Correspondence from Peter Schofield CB, Permanent Secretary… 23 Nov 2023 0
Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology Pension Case HC 1005 14 Jun 2023 20 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

5 items
4 Recommendation Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology P… Accepted

Write to set out support for informed pension financial decisions within three months.

This is another case of government not giving people enough time or support to make complex financial decisions. The government has a role to help people make good financial decisions, because of the detriment that bad choices can lead to. In the case of AEAT, it should have done this …

Government response. The government agrees to write to the Committee detailing actions to support informed financial decisions regarding pensions. It cites specific initiatives already in place, such as the Stronger Nudge to Pensions Guidance and the national rollout of the mid-life MOT, …
HM Treasury
17 Conclusion Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology P… Accepted

Government provided insufficient and misleading information with restrictive one-month deadline for AEAT pension decisions.

The AEAT case is one where government directly provided information intended to help pension scheme members decide what to do with their accrued pension benefits. Members were only given one month to make the decision, and consider that the information provided was insufficient and misleading.36 GAD acknowledged that in the …

Government response. The government agrees with the recommendation and will inform the Committee of actions taken to support informed pension decisions. They cite recent steps like the Stronger Nudge to Pensions Guidance, national mid-life MOT delivery, and new regulations for Pensions Dashboards.
HM Treasury
18 Conclusion Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology P… Accepted

Government and regulators consistently fail to adequately support individuals making complex financial decisions.

This committee has previously found similar issues with how government provides or oversees support for people making complex or long-term financial decisions, including through the regulation of independent financial advice. Most recently, our inquiry last year into the British Steel pension scheme found that pensions regulators had failed to provide …

Government response. The government agrees with the recommendation and will inform the Committee of actions taken to support informed pension decisions. They cite recent steps like the Stronger Nudge to Pensions Guidance, national mid-life MOT delivery, and new regulations for Pensions Dashboards.
HM Treasury
19 Conclusion Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology P… Accepted

Consumers and students lack adequate support to understand complex financial products and education choices.

This committee’s 2016 report on financial services mis-selling similarly concluded that the Financial Conduct Authority was not doing enough to ensure that consumers understand the financial products they are buying. The report found that even the most knowledgeable consumers can find financial services too complex to understand, which emphasises the …

Government response. The government agrees with the recommendation and will inform the Committee of actions taken to support informed pension decisions. They cite recent steps like the Stronger Nudge to Pensions Guidance, national mid-life MOT delivery, and new regulations for Pensions Dashboards.
HM Treasury
20 Conclusion Fifty-Seventh Report - AEA Technology P… Accepted

DWP initiatives for improving pension financial advice lack clear timelines for tangible improvements.

We asked DWP how government can ensure it gives clearer and more accessible financial advice in similar situations in future. DWP told us that changes to policy on privatisations and transfers of pensions meant that the specific circumstances affecting 33 Qq 50–51; C&AG’s Report, paras 3.10–3.11 34 Qq 44, 51 …

Government response. The government agrees, committing to write to the Committee by September 2023 to outline actions for supporting informed pension decisions through advice, guidance, and reduced complexity, alongside ongoing initiatives like the Stronger Nudge and Pensions Dashboards.
HM Treasury

Oral evidence sessions

1 session
Date Witnesses
13 Mar 2023 Karl Banister · Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, Martin Clarke · Government Actuary’s Department (GAD), Tom Josephs · Department for Work and Pensions View ↗

Correspondence

3 letters
DateDirectionTitle
11 Jul 2023 Correspondence from William Wragg MP, Public Administration and Constitutional …
17 Apr 2023 Correspondence from Tom Josephs, Director, Private Pensions and Arm’s Length Bo…
17 Apr 2023 Correspondence from Martin Clarke, Government Actuary, Government Actuary’s Dep…