Source · Select Committees · Human Rights (Joint Committee)

Recommendation 42

42 Not Addressed

There is significant concern that public buyers, such as local authorities, will not have sufficient...

Conclusion
There is significant concern that public buyers, such as local authorities, will not have sufficient capacity to use discretionary powers effectively. (Conclusion, Paragraph 223)
Government Response Summary
The government details the existing Procurement Act, stating it is the responsibility of contracting authorities to use discretionary exclusion grounds, but does not address the committee's specific concern about their capacity to do so effectively.
Government Response Not Addressed
HM Government Not Addressed
The Procurement Act outlines the process for considering exclusions which contracting authorities must follow. The Act distinguishes between mandatory and discretionary exclusion grounds. Mandatory exclusion grounds cover the most serious, high risk scenarios. Discretionary exclusion grounds represent situations that may pose unacceptable risks. Where a discretionary exclusion ground applies, contracting authorities have an option to exclude suppliers on a case-by-case basis. It is the responsibility of contracting authorities to consider whether bidders meet the grounds for exclusion, and if appropriate to then exclude them from a competition. Discretion provides contracting authorities with the flexibility to consider the list of factors that are relevant based on the procurement in question. As the list of factors and potentially applicable exclusion grounds that are relevant will change, based on the procurement and the relevant supplier’s circumstances, it would not be appropriate to set a general baseline as to how frequently suppliers should be excluded on the basis of discretionary grounds. Contracting authorities must notify the Procurement Review Unit in the Cabinet Office, via the notification form on the PRU landing page on gov.uk, within 30 days of excluding a supplier, stating the exclusions ground.