Select committee: Justice Committee
Recommendation 7
Fifth Report - Open justice: court reporting in the digital age
Published 1 Nov 2022
Paragraph 33
Addressed to Ministry of Justice
Justice Committee Open justice: court reporting in the digital age All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Recommendation (the committee's words)
As the public receives less information through the media on the work of the courts, HMCTS should do more to enable the courts to communicate information on court proceedings directly to the public. In addition, HMCTS needs to use technology and organisational reform, building on the work done with Courtsdesk News, to provide the media with the information it needs in a consistent manner, as soon as possible, to facilitate court reporting. HMCTS should also pilot the use of regional communication and information officers to support media and public access to hearings. Furthermore, the decrease in the media’s coverage of the courts also strengthens the case for the re- establishment of a courts’ inspectorate, which could help to identify wider issues within the justice system, particularly in the Magistrates’ courts and the Family Court, which are not well covered by the media.
From: Justice Committee, Fifth Report - Open justice: court reporting in the digital age (HC 339), paragraph 33, 1 November 2022
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 16 January 2023 (deadline 1 January 2023).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The Government states that it "remains committed to upholding the principle of open justice" and responds to the Committee's recommendations by citing existing and planned work, a 2023 call for evidence, and some stated reasons for not taking forward certain recommendations.
- On legislating for open justice, the Government says it sees "no clear need to legislate in this area", citing common law, Article 6 ECHR and the flexibility this gives the judiciary.
- On re-establishing a courts' inspectorate, it says "the case for re-establishing a courts' inspectorate is therefore not clear", citing existing audit, management information and parliamentary scrutiny.
- It commits that "in 2023" it will develop and publish a charter for members of the public summarising existing rules on access to hearings and information. It says the charter would not create new rights.
- On a PACER-style document portal, it states "we do not, at this stage, have plans" to create one, citing resources, and says it plans to explore access to court documents in a call for evidence launching in 2023.