Select committee: Work and Pensions Committee
Recommendation 10
Second Report - Benefit levels in the UK
Published 21 Mar 2024
Paragraph 109
Addressed to Department for Work and Pensions
Work and Pensions Committee Benefit levels in the UK All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Recommendation (the committee's words)
We understand that to increase legacy benefits, changes must be made to DWP IT systems several months in advance—with work needing to be completed by the end of November, for increases to be enacted the following April. Parliament however is not presented with the secondary legislation to approve these changes until months after the decision is announced, by which time it would not be possible for the Government to change its course should it be persuaded. We are concerned that the process does not provide genuine opportunity for Members to scrutinise the Government’s plans. The Government should devise and bring forward further opportunities for Parliament to scrutinise its decisions on benefit uprating. For example, ahead of debate on the benefit Uprating Order, the Government should provide this Committee with a statement of how its decision on benefit uprating has taken into account its newly stated set of principles and objectives.
From: Work and Pensions Committee, Second Report - Benefit levels in the UK (HC 142), paragraph 109, 21 March 2024
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 23 May 2024 (deadline 21 May 2024).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The government's response sets out where it has taken action, but it gives no commitment to the Committee's main proposals on benchmarks, an 'Uprating Guarantee', independent research or a permanent Household Support Fund.
- On a benchmark for income-replacement benefits, it states it "does not intend to establish a benchmark"; it notes there is "no overall agreed approach to benchmark benefit levels".
- It "agrees that PIP is not operating as intended" and points to the Health and Disability Green Paper of 29 April 2024. On the Extra Costs Taskforce it says it would "not be appropriate to further comment" until the consultation response is published.
- On uprating, it has "no plans to change the uprating process" and no plans to change the gap between the inflation measure and implementation. LHA rates will be reviewed every year, taking into account "a range of factors".
- It has no plans to commission further research on benefit levels and health, or independent research on whether levels meet objectives. The Household Support Fund is extended for six months, not made permanent. It will release Work Coach and Disability Employment Adviser statistics quarterly.