Recommendation 19

Disproportionate use of personal guarantees may be a factor in driving down access to finance, either owing to lack of collateral or simple risk aversion from businesses who do not wish to take them out. We support the FCA’s investigation into the fair and proportionate use of personal guarantees that fall within its existing remit. The FCA’s remit is set by Parliament, and we do not feel that widening it would be appropriate at this time. This is because the unintended consequences of introducing new regulatory frameworks to deal with specific issues in SME lending market could actually result in a reduction in the accessibility of finance for SMEs. We may revisit this in the future and will monitor the FCA’s progress on the matter of personal guarantees.