Select committee: Transport Committee
Conclusion 16
Second Report - The Integrated Rail Plan for the North and Midlands
Published 27 Jul 2022
Paragraph 68
Addressed to Department for Transport
Transport Committee Integrated Rail Plan All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Conclusion (the committee's words)
Local stakeholders and the Government have very different views on the likely merit and cost of the underground station option at Manchester Piccadilly. There are considerable cost and practical challenges to delivering this solution, though we recognise the benefits of a through station and saving land for development. We have heard concerns that there has been a lack of direct engagement and a paucity of detail shared about the basis for the Government’s decision not to opt for an underground station.
From: Transport Committee, Second Report - The Integrated Rail Plan for the North and Midlands (HC 292), paragraph 68, 27 July 2022
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 13 July 2023 (deadline 27 September 2022).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The Government welcomes the report and sets out a mixed response: it accepts several recommendations, some with caveats on timing, but does not accept that the Integrated Rail Plan "underserves the rail needs of the North of England".
- On the Golborne Link, it "accepts the rationale" for the recommendation but says the work will take longer than suggested; it remains "committed to looking at alternatives" and safeguarding is to be maintained meanwhile.
- It does not accept that the overall evidence base needs to be reconsidered, citing similar outputs, the adaptive approach and "significant" cost differentials of alternatives.
- It accepts the recommendation on HS2 to Leeds, will publish terms of reference "before the summer recess" and anticipates the study taking "around 18 months", while stating that the study "does not guarantee further interventions will be agreed or progressed".
- It "notes" the recommendation on a Manchester Piccadilly underground station and continues to believe a combined surface station is best placed to meet the needs of both HS2 and NPR services.