Recommendations & Conclusions
17 items
1
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
Fuel duty and vehicle excise duty raise some £35 billion a year. Approximately 20% of that revenue is disbursed on maintaining and developing the roads. Neither fuel duty nor vehicle excise duty are currently levied on electric vehicles. The Government is phasing out the sale of petrol and diesel cars …
Government response. As the Government’s Net Zero Strategy set out, as we transition to net zero, the government will need to ensure that the tax system encourages the uptake of EVs, and revenue from motoring taxes will need to keep pace with …
Department for Transport
2
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must start an honest conversation with the public on the funding implications for road development and maintenance and for other essential public services of decreased revenue from vehicle excise duty and fuel duty.
Government response. As the Government’s Net Zero Strategy set out, as we transition to net zero, the government will need to ensure that the tax system encourages the uptake of EVs, and revenue from motoring taxes will need to keep pace with …
Department for Transport
3
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
To promote fairness and public acceptance, any alternative road charging mechanism must (a) entirely replace fuel duty and vehicle excise duty rather than being added alongside those taxes; and (b) be revenue neutral with most motorists paying the same or less than they do currently.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
4
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
Zero fuel duty and vehicle excise duty help motorists to offset the higher purchase price of electric vehicles compared with petrol and diesel alternatives. Those prices are predicted to decrease as sales of new and second-hand electric vehicles increase. As prices decrease, more motorists will purchase electric vehicles, which will …
Government response. As the Government’s Net Zero Strategy set out, as we transition to net zero, the government will need to ensure that the tax system encourages the uptake of EVs, and revenue from motoring taxes will need to keep pace with …
Department for Transport
5
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
In signalling a shift to any alternative road charging mechanism, the Government must make it clear to motorists who purchase electric vehicles that they will be required to pay for road usage, as is currently the case for petrol and diesel vehicles. It must ensure that any alternative road charging …
Government response. As the Government’s Net Zero Strategy set out, as we transition to net zero, the government will need to ensure that the tax system encourages the uptake of EVs, and revenue from motoring taxes will need to keep pace with …
Department for Transport
6
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
In designing a replacement for fuel duty and vehicle excise duty, the Government must examine how an alternative road pricing mechanism can use price as a lever for change while subjecting motorists to fair levels of taxation. To that end, it may seek to make concessions in the interests of …
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
7
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The introduction of an alternative road charging mechanism that supported motoring and motorists might work against the Government’s ambition for half of all journeys in towns and cities to be walked or cycled by 2030. In designing an alternative road pricing mechanism to vehicle excise duty and fuel duty, the …
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
8
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must set out a range of options to replace fuel duty and vehicle excise duty. Those options should be revenue neutral and not cause drivers, as a whole, to pay more than they do currently. One of those options should be a road pricing mechanism that uses telematic …
Government response. The Government is focused on delivering its core priorities, as set out in the 2019 manifesto. As such, the government does not currently have plans to consider road pricing.
Department for Transport
9
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The taxes imposed by fuel duty and vehicle excise duty are increasingly duplicated by local schemes that charge motorists for entering congestion zones and clean air zones. New taxes, and particularly those that rely on new technology, take many years to introduce. The patchwork of devolved schemes may make it …
Government response. The Government is focused on delivering its core priorities, as set out in the 2019 manifesto. As such, the government does not currently have plans to consider road pricing.
Department for Transport
10
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must examine how an alternative road pricing mechanism can be delivered alongside devolved local road charging schemes, while respecting the existing devolution settlement. Any alternative road pricing mechanism must be revenue neutral to the Government rather than causing drivers, as a whole, to pay more than they do …
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
11
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must examine the role that telematic technology can play in delivering a replacement road pricing mechanism that sets the cost of motoring based on the duration and time of the journey and vehicle type and size.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
12
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must assess the potential effect of telematic technology on changing drivers’ behaviour and delivering its wider policies on air quality, congestion, public transport and public health.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
13
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must assess the potential effect of a road pricing mechanism based on telematic technology on high-mileage drivers, such as road hauliers and those in rural communities, and on those least able to adapt to increased motoring costs.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
14
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The successful implementation of a national, technology-based road pricing scheme is contingent on the Government explaining how data capture will work in practice, ensuring that data management is subject to rigorous governance and oversight and reassuring the public that their privacy will be protected.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
15
Recommendation
Fourth Report - Road pricing
The Government must work on a cross-departmental basis to ensure that equal focus and policy ownership is placed on the delivery of more zero emission vehicles and the continued funding and maintenance of the road network. The Treasury and the DfT should set up a joint unit including Ministers and …
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
16
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
Bearing in mind the partial devolution of transport policy, consultation and agreement between the UK Government and the devolved Administrations will be key to developing and implementing an alternative road charging mechanism.
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport
17
Conclusion
Fourth Report - Road pricing
To fulfil their respective and connected responsibilities for managing congestion and maintaining the public finances, the DfT and the Treasury must jointly establish an arm’s-length body with an appointed individual to evaluate its preferred options to replace fuel duty and vehicle excise duty [see paragraph 26]. The body should consult …
Government response. Given this, the Government does not have further views on the Committee’s recommendations for the ways in which road pricing should be considered.
Department for Transport