Select committee: Scottish Affairs Committee

Conclusion 98

Second Report - Welfare policy in Scotland Published 23 Jun 2021 Addressed to Scotland Office
Conclusion (the committee's words)
Many of the stakeholders told us that increasing the amount of money that claimants receive through Universal Credit would be effective in reducing poverty in Scotland. We heard from Kirsty McKechnie at the Child Poverty Action Group that ‘the way to alleviate poverty is to give people more money and to put the money into people’s pockets so that it becomes a cash-first response to these issues.’237 Nina Ballantyne from Citizens Advice Scotland agreed with this point of view saying that people should be given ‘enough [money] to live on’238 and highlighted that increasing the adequacy of Universal Credit ‘prevents additional strain on public services elsewhere.’239 Professor McKendrick, Glasgow 233 Department for Work and Pensions, Universal Credit: What you’ll get, April 2021 234 The Trussell Trust (WPS0006) 235 Q105 236 Q63 237 Q84 238 Q84 239 Q84 Welfare policy in Scotland 39 Caledonian University, agreed saying that the ‘root of the problem is the adequacy of the income’.240 He argued that ‘most people know how to manage their money. They just need enough money to manage.’241

From: Scottish Affairs Committee, Second Report - Welfare policy in Scotland (HC 55), 23 June 2021

Government response

The government responded to the whole report on 19 November 2021 (deadline 23 August 2021).

Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.

The UK Government "notes the Committee's recommendations" and responds to each in turn, accepting little of the report's welfare-policy proposals and referring several to the Scottish Government.

  • On the £20 uplift and legacy benefits, it states "There was never any plan to extend the uplift to legacy benefits."
  • On work allowances, it states it "has no plans to extend the work allowance to single adults".
  • On Help to Claim funding, it "considers the existing resource to be sufficient", and says DWP agreed to fund Citizens Advice Scotland for another year, "up to 31 March 2022".
  • On data sharing and Recommendations 2, 7 and 8, it says each data request "must be examined" by DWP as Data Controller, and treats several recommendations as "for the Scottish Government".

Read the government's response ↗ Report an error