Select committee: Home Affairs Committee
Conclusion 3
Sixth Report - Police Conduct and Complaints
Published 1 Mar 2022
Paragraph 28
Addressed to Home Office
Home Affairs Committee Police conduct and complaints All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Conclusion (the committee's words)
The question arose during our inquiry whether the IOPC should be staffed by investigators who were not former police officers. Opinion divided on whether those who had served in the police should be excluded for potentially ‘marking their own homework’ or that of their colleagues. On the other side of the argument, ex-police officers bring the skills learned on the job and an understanding of police culture. It seems that an appropriate balance of former serving officers and investigators with other backgrounds is the right one to strike, but it may be that the IOPC should seek to widen its pool of potential candidates to include those with investigative experience from other spheres, including, for example, former military personnel.
From: Home Affairs Committee, Sixth Report - Police Conduct and Complaints (HC 140), paragraph 28, 1 March 2022
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 28 April 2022 (deadline 1 May 2022).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The Government welcomes the Committee's recognition of progress and agrees that improving the police complaints and discipline systems is ongoing, but it declines the Committee's call for an early assessment of PCC involvement and says it will look at the IOPC's governance as part of a periodic review.
- On appointing an independent IOPC chair, the Government does not commit to the change. It agrees the governance structure "should be looked at" in the first periodic review of the IOPC, which it expects "to start early in 2022/23".
- On an early assessment of PCC involvement in complaints, it says "we cannot now agree" because the PCC review concluded before the report. It will "in due course" assess the impact of the February 2020 complaints reforms.
- On bi-annual monitoring of how local policing bodies hold forces to account for implementing IOPC recommendations, and on joined-up reporting of IOPC, HMICFRS and Coroners' recommendations, it says it "will consider" with the IOPC how to go further.
- It commits to update the police super-complaints website to say designated bodies should collaborate with non-designated organisations. It says it will respond to the Macpherson report in May.