Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Glasgow Caledonian University

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201707870 Sector Education Category academic appeal / exam results / degree classification Decided 01 December 2018

View Glasgow Caledonian University scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C complained that the university's handling of his academic appeal was unreasonable. Mr C said that university staff marking his work were biased against him because of a previous disciplinary matter.

We found that the university acted in line with their Academic Appeals Policy and Procedure. In their response to Mr C's academic appeal, the university explained why Mr C's supervisor, who had given evidence in relation to the disciplinary matter, had been involved with the marking due to the need for supervisors to provide specific comments. They also explained that other staff, who had no involvement with the previous disciplinary matter, had been allocated to mark his work to ensure impartiality. In addition, an external examiner had reviewed Mr  C's work and approved the mark awarded, as well as the overall degree classification.

We found that the university's handling of Mr C's academic appeal was reasonable. Therefore, we did not uphold Mr C's complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201707870 as a PDF (23.76 KB) Updated: December 19, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Glasgow Caledonian University

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201702374 01 Sep 2018 Ms C complained about the university’s handling of her complaint, in particular that the university did not deal with all … Not Upheld
201703229 01 May 2018 Mrs C raised allegations in her academic appeal that she was victim of racial discrimination, both in the marking and … Partly Upheld
201604173 01 Aug 2017 Mr C complained about the university's handling of his complaint, and about financial redress offered to him by the university. … Not Upheld
201605965 01 Aug 2017 Mr C complained in his own right and on behalf of a fellow student (Ms A). He complained that the … Not Upheld
201605940 01 Jun 2017 Miss C complained that her university failed to provide adequate guidance for her first attempt at her dissertation. She also … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation