Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

North Ayrshire Health and Social Care Partnership

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Upheld Reference 201703417 Sector Health and Social Care Category home helps / concessions / grants / charges for services Decided 01 March 2019

Full decision

Summary

Mr C, a solicitor, complained on behalf of his client (Mrs A) and her power of attorney that the partnership failed to act reasonably in relation to the assessment of capital. Mrs A and her late husband (Mr B) purchased a property, the title of which was subject to a survivorship destination (a property that is jointly owned and on death of one of the owners, their share will pass to the survivor). Mrs A was diagnosed with dementia and moved into residential care. Mr B was diagnosed with terminal cancer and shortly before his death, he evacuated the destination meaning his share of the property would no longer go to Mrs A on his death. The partnership considered that Mr B's actions were a deliberate attempt to deprive Mrs A of capital due to the timing and circumstances of it, and began charging Mrs A for residential care from the date of Mr B's death. Mr C argued that as a survivor destination the property only ever potentially belonged to Mrs  A, and it was possible for Mr B to change his intentions on inheritance at anytime.

We took independent legal advice in our consideration of this complaint. We concluded that the partnership did not fully consider the relevant guidance in relation to their financial assessment of Mrs A's capital, nor did they properly assess the value of that capital. We upheld Mr C's complaint.

Recommendations

What we asked the organisation to do in this case: The council should carry out a new financial assessment on the basis of our findings.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201703417 as a PDF (25.07 KB) Updated: March 20, 2019

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving North Ayrshire Health and Social Care P…

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202202759 01 Aug 2024 C’s elderly, visually impaired and partially deaf parent (A) was in receipt of social care from the partnership. C raised … Upheld
202009025 01 Nov 2022 C and their partner (B) complained about the actions of the partnership’s social work department. B’s sibling (A) had been … Upheld
201702572 01 Feb 2021 C complained about the partnership's decision to conduct Adult Support and Protection (ASP) enquiries following receipt of concerns about their … Not Upheld
201802848 01 Sep 2020 Mr C complained that the partnership failed to take account of relevant evidence when reviewing priorities for the provision of … Not Upheld
201806426 01 Aug 2020 Mr C, a support and advocacy worker, complained on behalf of his client (Ms A). Ms A had been receiving … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation