Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

University of Aberdeen

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201604681 Sector Education Category academic appeal/exam results/degree classification Decided 01 May 2017

View The University of Aberdeen scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C complained that the university failed to follow the correct procedures when assessing her exam. She was also unhappy that when she requested a copy of their standard operating procedure (SOP) for the assessment of the exam they provided the incorrect document. She also complained that they failed to consider her appeal in line with their appeals process.

We found that the university should have provided the SOP when this was requested. We also noted that they failed to arrange an appeal hearing within the timescale required by their appeals process. As a result, we upheld these elements of the complaint.

We did not find failings in the way Ms C's exam was assessed and did not uphold this element of her complaint. We did accept that the SOP was open to interpretation and we suggested to the university that they give consideration to reviewing this document to provide greater clarity.

Recommendations

We recommended that the university: write to Ms C to apologise for the initial failure to provide her with the correct documentation she requested; ensure that staff know how to respond to a freedom of information request; and write to Ms C to apologise for the delay in arranging the panel hearing.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201604681 as a PDF (12.83 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving University of Aberdeen

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201703195 01 Oct 2018 Ms C complained that the university failed to provide reasonable supervision and monitoring during her full-time PhD course. Ms C … Upheld
201508572 01 Feb 2017 Mr C complained on behalf of Mr A. Mr A had previously submitted an academic appeal to the University of … Partly Upheld
201501382 01 Dec 2015 Miss C started a part-time distance learning masters degree course at the university. Within a few weeks she found that … Not Upheld
201403588 01 Aug 2015 In the fourth year of his Masters degree, Mr C's dissertation was found to contain work taken from other sources … Not Upheld
201203117 01 May 2013 Mr C was unhappy with the academic appeals process that he had to follow when he claimed that his dissertation … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation