Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Lothian NHS Board - Acute Division

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201602038 Sector Health Category clinical treatment / diagnosis Decided 01 May 2017

View NHS Lothian scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C complained about the board's decision not to offer him surgical treatment for his condition. The board said that the decision to proceed with surgery was subject to the Adult Exceptional Aesthetic Referral Protocol, which details the limited criteria in which surgery can be provided for a range of conditions. The board said that because Mr C did not meet criteria within this protocol, he did not qualify for surgery for his condition.

We found that Mr C was assessed by a plastic surgery registrar and a clinical psychologist before a multi-disciplinary team made a decision on whether Mr C met the criteria. We took independent advice from a consultant plastic and reconstructive surgeon and a consultant psychiatrist. Based on the advice we received, we concluded that the assessments carried out prior to the decision-making were reasonable. Although we found that the board had not undertaken the assessments in the order specified within the protocol, the advisers did not consider that this would have prejudiced the subsequent decision of the multi-disciplinary team. We concluded that the board's decision not to offer Mr C surgery was reasonable, and for this reason we did not uphold this complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201602038 as a PDF (11.15 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Lothian NHS Board - Acute Division

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202301188 01 Dec 2024 C complained that Lothian NHS Board (Board 1) unreasonably failed to maintain records of specialist advice they provided to another … Partly Upheld
202301420 01 Nov 2024 C complained that the board failed to provide them with appropriate orthopaedic (specialists in the treatment of diseases and injuries … Not Upheld
202208872 01 Nov 2024 C complained about the care and treatment that their late parent (A) received while in hospital. A suffered a fall … Upheld
202303330 01 Sep 2024 C complained about the care and treatment that they received from the board. C underwent a left total hip replacement … Upheld
202208467 01 Sep 2024 C complained about the nursing care and treatment provided to their late parent (A). A had a fall during an … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation