Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Grampian NHS Board

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Upheld Reference 201507758 Sector Health Category admission / discharge / transfer procedures Decided 01 June 2016

View NHS Grampian scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mrs C complained about the care and treatment provided to her late mother (Mrs A). Mrs C raised concerns that hospital staff at Dr Gray's Hospital unreasonably arranged to transfer Mrs A to Turner Memorial Hospital. Prior to the transfer, Mrs C had been treated in Dr Gray's Hospital for her existing chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (a disease of the lungs in which the airways become narrowed). Mrs C said Mrs A had suffered diarrhoea on the day of the transfer and looked unwell.

The board said Mrs A's transfer had been reasonable. They said there was no evidence of diarrhoea prior to transfer, and Mrs A had been appropriately transferred.

After receiving independent advice from a geriatrician, we upheld Mrs C's complaints. We found that staff had unreasonably transferred Mrs A. In particular, we considered that Mrs A's condition was unstable, and her transfer was not subject to an appropriate level of consideration. We also considered that the board did not comply with the 'Can I help you?' guidance in answering Mrs C's complaint. We made a number of recommendations to address these concerns.

Recommendations

We recommended that the board: apologise to the family for the failings identified; confirm that the staff responsible will discuss this issue as part of their annual appraisal; remind staff of the importance of adequate record-keeping; and remind relevant staff of the complaints handling requirements under the 'Can I help you?' guidance.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201507758 as a PDF (13.35 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Grampian NHS Board

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202504517 01 May 2026 C complained about the care and treatment that they received in A&E, and the subsequent handling of their complaint by … Upheld
202401974 01 May 2026 C complained about the standard of care provided to their parent (A) by the board in relation to a scan … Upheld
202501264 01 Mar 2026 C complained about the care and treatment that their spouse (A) received from the board during admissions to Dr Gray’s … Upheld
202402498 01 Sep 2025 C complained that the board failed to carry out their sibling (A)'s hip replacement surgery within a reasonable time. C … Upheld
202305315 01 Aug 2025 C, a Patient Advice and Support Service (PASS) adviser, complained on behalf of their client (B) about the care and … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation