Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Shetland Islands Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201404803 Sector Local Government Category handling of application (complaints by applicants) Decided 01 March 2016

View Shetland Islands Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C requested a variation to a planning permission granted to him. The original permission allowed the building of a house and outbuildings, but restricted the use of the outbuildings. Mr C wished to remove the restriction on business use for one outbuilding. He also wanted retrospective approval for the installation of a flue for a wood-burning stove in an outbuilding. The house had not been constructed at this time.

Mr C had engaged in extensive correspondence with the council about possible changes to the planning conditions. The council had responded to these, but had noted that he should seek independent planning advice. Mr C had submitted an application for retrospective planning permission for the stove flue, but this had been rejected.

Mr C complained that the council had not provided reasonable advice on altering the planning condition. He said that they had incorrectly stated he did not have permitted development rights to build the flue for the wood-burning stove. He also complained they had not responded reasonably to his complaint.

We took independent advice from a planning adviser. The adviser said that the council had acted reasonably and proportionally in dealing with Mr C and in the advice provided by planning officers. We found the council had acted reasonably. Mr C had not taken independent planning advice, despite planning officers suggesting that he do so, and he had agreed to the planning application as submitted. The council had responded appropriately to his complaint, although it was accepted that he disagreed with their position.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201404803 as a PDF (11.29 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Shetland Islands Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201908492 01 Mar 2021 C, a support and advocacy worker, submitted a complaint on behalf of their clients (A and B) regarding the support … Not Upheld
201801567 01 Mar 2019 Mr C, an MSP, complained on behalf of his constituent, that the council failed to arrange a suitable care package … Not Upheld
201700875 01 Sep 2018 Mr C's child attends a school which is just under two miles from home, along a rural road. They receive … Upheld
201601136 01 Jun 2017 Mr C complained about the way the council managed his planning application to build a new home. Approval was granted … Partly Upheld
201400823 01 Dec 2015 Mr C complained that the council had failed to assess a planning application for a house next to his property. … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation