Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

South Ayrshire Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201402879 Sector Local Government Category policy/administration Decided 01 May 2015

View South Derbyshire Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C complained that the council's regulatory panel had granted planning consent for a radio mast in the garden of a neighbour despite having been given photographic evidence of the site which was out-of-date. Since the original photographs of the site were taken by planning officers a number of trees had been felled which Mr C said altered the screening of the site. Mr C was of the view that the council should have taken new photographs after the felling had taken place and should also have issued a new and updated report of handling to objectors to the development.

In responding to the complaint the council said that the regulatory panel was fully aware of the felling that had taken place as the son of the applicant had informed them of the changes. In addition, an objector had written to highlight the felling and Mr C himself had spoken at the panel hearing and highlighted this issue. The regulatory panel chose not to visit the site or require updated photographic evidence as they did not consider it necessary to determine the application.

We considered Mr C's complaint and found that the regulatory panel had been made fully aware of the felling which had taken place and had the opportunity to request further information. As they did not consider this was required, however, they determined the application. We also found that the council had no responsibility to issue a new and updated report of handling following the tree felling and that, even if they had, they would not be obliged to issue copies of this document to objectors. As we did not find evidence of administrative failure in the way these matters were dealt with by the council, we did not uphold the complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201402879 as a PDF (11.34 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving South Ayrshire Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202201541 01 Jun 2024 C complained on behalf of their relative (A) and A’s child (B) about the health and social care partnership, of … Partly Upheld
201903957 01 Sep 2020 C complained about two incidents involving their child (A) and another child at school. C said that child protection procedures … Not Upheld
201900179 01 Jun 2020 Ms C complained on behalf of her adult son (Mr A) regarding two specific matters. The first concerned child protection … Partly Upheld
201808261 01 Jun 2020 Ms C had concerns in relation to changes to the recycling system introduced by the council. Ms C told the … Partly Upheld
201707958 01 Jul 2019 Ms C complained about the decision to withdraw funding from her father's (Mr A) care home placement. The council believed … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation