Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

University of Edinburgh

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201400964 Sector Education Category academic appeal/exam results/degree classification Decided 01 October 2014

View The University of Edinburgh scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C was very ill during the third year of his honours degree and, after being admitted to hospital, was diagnosed with a significant illness. He submitted a special circumstances application for the exams he was about to take.

When some six months later, at the end of his third year, Mr C received a fail mark for a second semester subject he said he was disadvantaged because he had missed foundation knowledge due to his absence through illness. He asked for his special circumstances to be taken into account for that subject. Mr C said he was given advice and reassurances that his submission of special circumstances for that subject would be considered at the end of his fourth year. He said the advice he was given was poor and that the reassurances given at the end of his third year were misleading.

When he received his final honours degree award he submitted an appeal to the university about his grading because he felt the low mark awarded in third year had impacted upon his overall grade at the end of his degree. He said the university had not properly considered the impact of his special circumstances, which he had been told they would do at the end of his final year. He complained that proper procedures had not been followed in dealing with his special circumstances and appeal.

Our investigation found that the university had fully considered the impact of his special circumstances and had followed their policy and procedures in dealing with his case, so we did not uphold Mr C’s complaints.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201400964 as a PDF (11.28 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving University of Edinburgh

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202201211 01 Jun 2023 C complained about how the university handled their complaint that related to their disability and housing. We found that the … Upheld
201903883 01 Dec 2020 C, a solicitor, complained on behalf of their client (A) who was formerly an international student at the university. A … Not Upheld
201800154 01 Oct 2020 C was enrolled on a programme at the University of Edinburgh. C complained about the university's response to reports of … Not Upheld
201803667 01 Sep 2020 C complained about the university's handling of their complaint in relation to language used by an external tutor that C … Upheld
201807417 01 Nov 2019 Mr C complained about the university’s handling of an academic appeal. Mr C had appealed a decision reached by the … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation