Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

University of St Andrews

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201305880 Sector Education Category policy/administration Decided 01 July 2014

View The University of St. Andrews scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C, who was a student, asked for a training placement near her home. She explained that she needed this on the grounds of mitigating circumstances, as she had to care for a family member. The university declined her request and placed her in another location. Ms C complained to us that the university unreasonably failed to adhere to their mitigating circumstances criteria in dealing with her request.

We looked at information from Ms C and the university. The university information included their policy for allocating student placements and taking into account mitigating circumstances. It was not, however, for us to say whether Ms C's mitigating circumstances were valid, which was a decision for the university. Our role was to look at whether they dealt with Ms C's mitigating circumstances claim in line with their policy and procedures.

The university explained how the relevant committee considered Ms C's claim, and the evidence showed they did so with empathy. The university also explained why the committee decided that the circumstances Ms C detailed, and the supporting evidence she provided to them, did not meet their mitigating circumstances criteria. We found that they had considered the placement request and Miss C's mitigating circumstances claim in line with their allocation policy.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201305880 as a PDF (11.14 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving University of St Andrews

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202409674 01 Aug 2025 C, an EU student with disabilities, began an MSc at the University of St Andrews. A few weeks later, their … Not Upheld
201805182 01 Oct 2021 C complained about the way that the university handled their complaint. We found that the university did not communicate clearly … Upheld
201804250 01 Oct 2019 Mr C, a lawyer, complained on behalf of his client (Ms A) regarding the university's handling of complaints she had … Not Upheld
201602119 01 Apr 2017 Ms C complained about the university's handling of her termination of studies, their consideration of her extenuating circumstances and her … Not Upheld
201507875 01 Dec 2016 Mr C suffered from a long-term illness of which he had made the university aware when he began his studies. … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation