Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Aberdeenshire Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) No Decision Reached Reference 201302949 Sector Local Government Category adoption procedures Decided 01 May 2014

View Aberdeenshire Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr and Mrs C complained about the council's handling of an adoption. They said that the council failed to alert them to legal issues that arose because of a change in legislation,and led to significant delay and expense. Mr and Mrs C also said that other prospective adopters had been treated differently and their adoptions had proceeded successfully. They said that they had been put under pressure about the way in which to progress the adoption.

In investigating the complaint, we considered all the relevant documentation, including the complaints correspondence, counsel's opinion and the council's adoption policy, and made further enquiries of the council. Our investigation found that much of the complaint hinged on the time taken by the court to release Mr and Mrs C's prospective daughter for adoption, and that this was a matter outside the council's control. Similarly, the council did not have control over other issues arising from the change in legislation. The council held particular views about the way to deal with these, with which Mr and Mrs C did not agree, but this was not in itself evidence of maladministration. Neither were the council responsible for the extra legal costs that occurred as a result of Mr and Mrs C's instructions to their solicitor. We noted that the council agreed to increase their usual financial contribution towards the legal fees in recognition of the difficult and different situation that had arisen. Overall, therefore, we did not find that the council had failed to take steps to expedite the adoption nor had they placed Mr and Mrs C under undue pressure.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201302949 as a PDF (11.35 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Aberdeenshire Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202302482 01 Dec 2024 C complained that the council had failed to keep their child (A) safe whilst in the council’s care and that … Partly Upheld
202110015 01 May 2024 C complained that the council had unreasonably failed to follow their own enforcement process and relevant planning guidance in response … Not Upheld
202102930 01 Aug 2023 C complained about the council's drainage assessment for a planning application. They said it only considered the likely impact of … Not Upheld
202109163 01 Jul 2023 C’s child (A), was a pupil at a school in the council’s area. C said that A experienced bullying and … Partly Upheld
202108990 01 Jul 2023 C complained that the council failed to provide support to them and their child (A), who had a severe and … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation