Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Dundee City Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201203475 Sector Local Government Category sheltered housing and community care Decided 01 July 2013

View Derby City Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mrs C moved back to the council's area to care for family. She accepted the council’s offer of an upper villa flat which had an intercom service to wardens in a nearby sheltered housing complex, although she was fit and active and had no need of the service. The council upgraded the intercom service at the start of 2012. Mrs C then began to be disturbed each morning with switchovers of warden shifts and an early call from the wardens to her downstairs neighbour, who was deaf. This caused her stress and she requested a house transfer. When Mrs C complained, the council disconnected her intercom service and insulated the cable conduit to reduce noise leakage between the two flats. The remaining problem was a matter of acoustic noise transference of conversations between the two properties.

Our investigation did not find grounds to uphold Mrs C’s complaint that the council had unreasonably failed to deal with the problems of the intercom system but in the circumstances, given Mrs C’s wish to move, we made a recommendation to address her concerns.

Recommendations

We recommended that the council: invite Mrs C to an interview with their letting centre to explore the possibilities of a mutual exchange and other housing options.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201203475 as a PDF (12.29 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Dundee City Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202204333 01 Aug 2023 C complained about the council's handling of reports they made about their neighbours' antisocial behaviour. They reported a number of … Upheld
202103458 01 Aug 2023 C complained that the council failed to respond appropriately to concerns they raised about their child (A) who had cancer. … Upheld
201903373 01 Aug 2020 C complained about the council’s actions in response to a child protection concern about their child (A) particularly about information … Upheld
201806506 01 Jul 2019 Ms C complained that the council unreasonably failed to carry out parenting capacity assessments to establish whether Ms C was … Partly Upheld
201802500 01 Jul 2019 Mr C is a kinship carer and he approached the council to apply for kinship care allowance. The council approved … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation