Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

The Highland Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201202845 Sector Local Government Category handling of application (complaints by opponents) Decided 01 September 2013

View The Highland Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C raised a number of issues about the council's strategic environmental assessment (SEA) for a proposed road development. He was concerned about the environmental report used in public consultation. He considered it to have been unclear and inaccurate, and said that the council should re-run the consultation. Mr C was also concerned that the environmental report did not take into account issues such as potential flooding and noise. He said that the council had also exaggerated the negative impact of one of the options to ensure that it was not selected.

We found that the council had taken Mr C's comments into account. They amended the report to reflect his comments about inaccuracies and corrected typographical errors. They also took steps to ensure clearer map information in the revised report. The council consulted with the appropriate agencies before preparing the report and we were, therefore, satisfied that they had included the necessary environmental issues in it. We also noted that the SEA was only one part of a process of environmental reviews to be carried out. While we noted the option Mr C favoured, and the amendments to this option that he suggested, we also took account of the council's statement that a number of options were selected at an earlier stage, using similar processes. We found no evidence to support his view that the council deliberately tried to ensure that this option had a higher environmental impact than necessary.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201202845 as a PDF (11.3 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving The Highland Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202206966 01 Apr 2024 C was living in a residential unit for young people who are looked after by the council. C complained that … Partly Upheld
202107467 01 Dec 2023 C complained about the council’s handling of allegations that their child made against them, including decisions taken to remove their … Partly Upheld
202002615 01 Apr 2023 C complained about the council’s decision-making in relation to the allocation of Scottish Government Town Centre funding. In terms of … Upheld
201909583 01 May 2021 C complained about the council's social work department's handling of child protection concerns that were raised about their children and … Upheld
201810255 01 Jan 2021 C complained about the council's involvement in respect of the Welfare Guardianship Order (order which allows someone to make ongoing … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation