Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Perth and Kinross Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201103257 Sector Local Government Category Traffic regulation and management Decided 01 June 2012

View Perth and Kinross Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C complained that for nine years he made numerous phone calls to the council's roads department about protecting his house from council waste trucks and heavy goods vehicles, which were mounting the pavement in front of his house. Mr C said he suggested that the council erect bollards to prevent this from happening but the roads department refused to do this as they felt that bollards would block the pavement for pedestrians. Mr C said the council failed to ensure that the pavement outside his home was safe or to ensure that his house was not being damaged by vibrations from vehicles bumping off the kerb.

Mr C said that in the council's final response to his complaint, they apologised for failings in dealing with his case and agreed to change the route used by council waste vehicles so that they would not mount the pavement outside Mr C's home. Mr C said that on receiving the letter, he contacted the council to ask what they were going to do about non council vehicles mounting the pavement. Mr C said the council told him that the re-routing of council waste trucks was 'as far as they could go'.

When we investigated the complaint, the council explained that the behaviour of those driving non-council vehicles did not fall within their jurisdiction and was a matter for the police. As the evidence showed that the council had dealt with the matters that were within their control (by rerouting the council vehicles) we did not uphold Mr C's complaints. However, as the evidence showed that the council did not include Mr C's concerns about non-council vehicles in their investigation of his complaint and did not respond on this point, we made a recommendation about this.

Recommendation We recommended that the council: • apologise to Mr C for failing: i) to include non-council vehicles in their investigation of his complaint; and ii) to then explain to him in their decision letter that they had no control over such vehicles and that the matter was for the police.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201103257 as a PDF (22.87 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Perth and Kinross Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202110970 01 Aug 2023 C complained that the council had unreasonably failed to carry out an adequate assessment of their parent (A)'s personal care … Upheld
202007694 01 Oct 2022 C complained about an incident in which their late parent (A) fell from their wheelchair prior to being assisted into … Not Upheld
201905582 01 Dec 2020 C complained on behalf of their family member (A). C was unhappy with the way the council’s social work service … Partly Upheld
201900916 01 Sep 2020 C and B complained about the council's communication with them when they were arranging a placement for their child (A) … Upheld
201902140 01 Sep 2020 C adopted a young child, however the placement ended after a short period of time and the child was removed … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation