Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Business Stream Ltd

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201102346 Sector Water Category Incorrect billing Decided 01 July 2012

Full decision

Summary

Mrs C runs a business that Scottish Water identified as receiving water without being billed. Business Stream took over the provision of water to the business in November 2010 and in January 2011 sent Mrs C a bill for outstanding water charges, which she found to be excessive. She asked for a water meter to be fitted to the premises so that she would only be billed for water used but, following a survey by Scottish Water, she was advised that this was not possible. Mrs C arranged for a plumber to inspect the pipework and he concluded that a meter could be fitted. This was done in June 2011. Mrs C complained that the water charges that accrued before the meter's installation were unreasonable and that the meter could have been installed several months earlier, lowering the costs.

Where no meter is in place, water charges are calculated on the rateable value of the property. We found it appropriate for these rates to apply up to the date of the meter being installed. In Mrs C's case, we were satisfied that the charges accrued prior to her meter being installed were in line with Business Stream's published rates. That said, during their inspection of Mrs C's premises, Scottish Water failed to identify that her pipework was suitable for the installation of a meter. They maintained this even after she highlighted her plumber's findings. We, therefore, concluded that there was an avoidable delay to the meter's installation.

Where Scottish Water are unable to fit a water meter, they will offer a contribution payment toward the cost of upgrading pipework so that installation can go ahead. Mrs C was offered a contribution of £750 and this was confirmed on more than one occasion. Scottish Water subsequently withdrew the offer, as no upgrade was required. We found Scottish Water’s communication about this to be poor, but that a good will gesture already offered by Business Stream was appropriate recompense. We also upheld Mrs C's complaint that Business Stream's complaint handling was poor and found that they had failed to offer her a £20 credit in line with their service standards.

Recommendations

We recommended that Business Stream: • recalculate Mrs C's water charges for the relevant period based on her metered usage and adjust the balance of her account accordingly; and • credit Mrs C's account with a further £20 in light of the failings identified.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201102346 as a PDF (23.72 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Business Stream Ltd

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201103715 01 Feb 2013 An employee of Scottish Water visited Mr C's business premises and advised that he was going to install a water … Upheld
201104142 01 Feb 2013 Mr C complained that Business Stream failed to read his meter between April 2011 and January 2012. He said that, … Partly Upheld
201201210 01 Feb 2013 Mr C complained on behalf of a golf club about Business Stream. He complained that Business Stream had sent the … Partly Upheld
201202733 01 Feb 2013 There was a leak in a pipe which fed a field trough. This was not detected and Ms C was … Partly Upheld
201200041 01 Feb 2013 Mr C complained about a lack of assistance from Business Stream when he attempted to investigate a suspected water leak … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation