Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

A Medical Practice, Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201100691 Sector Health Category clinical treatment/diagnosis Decided 01 February 2012

Full decision

Summary

Ms C had been on Depo-Provera contraceptive injections for a number of years, from 1994-2002, then from around 2005-2010. In May 2010 she developed back pain and other symptoms which she reported to the GPs at her local surgery. She was given various possible causes but after referral to a dermatologist, rheumatologist and an MRI scan she was eventually diagnosed in February 2011 with a probable chronic syndrome.

Ms C considers that had her contraceptive medication been appropriately monitored she would not have developed the condition ‘SAPHO syndrome’. She also considers that the GPs failed to diagnose her syndrome.

Our medical adviser considered the case and found that the monitoring of Ms C's contraceptive use, particularly in the earlier years had lacked detail. He found that blood pressure monitoring had been sporadic and there was no evidence of systematic review of the method of contraception. The adviser noted guidelines regarding review periods had not been issued until 2004, and that the notes had improved significantly from 2010 onwards – nonetheless the complaint regarding monitoring was upheld.

In relation to investigation and diagnosis, the adviser found the GPs’ actions to be a demonstration of good practice, in that appropriate and detailed referrals to specialist departments were made timeously. The adviser also found the probable syndrome was extremely rare and would not have expected a GP to diagnose it. Finally, no causative link between the contraceptive and SAPHO syndrome has been established. We did not uphold this complaint.

Recommendation We recommended that the practice: • apologise to Ms C for failing to monitor her appropriately whilst she was on Depo-Provera.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201100691 as a PDF (19.92 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving A Medical Practice, Greater Glasgow and…

Reference Date Summary Outcome
200903567 01 Jan 2012 Mrs C told us that she accompanied her daughter to the medical centre to see a doctor, as her daughter … Partly Upheld
201100468 01 Dec 2011 Mr C complained about the care and treatment that his late mother (Mrs A) received from her medical practice prior … Not Upheld
201100796 01 Dec 2011 Mrs C complained about the actions of a GP who attended her father (Mr A) at home. She was unhappy … Not Upheld
201004348 01 Aug 2011 Mr C was a new patient at the practice and his medical records had not yet arrived. While the practice … Upheld
201002571 01 Aug 2011 Mr C raised concerns about a telephone consultation that he had with his GP. He was suffering from severe lower … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation