Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

A Medical Practice, Lothian NHS Board

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201004700 Sector Health Category clinical treatment; diagnosis Decided 01 March 2012

Full decision

Summary

Ms C fell and slipped on ice. Some days later, she began to feel pain and her GP diagnosed a fractured tailbone. Approximately two weeks after the fall, she was rushed to hospital where she was diagnosed with an abscess. As a result of the abscess, she had to have surgery and it was some time before she made a full recovery.

Ms C complained to the practice about the misdiagnosis and also about the attitude of the GP during the visit. We sought advice from our independent medical adviser who confirmed that, from a clinical standpoint, the initial consultation had failed to achieve the correct diagnosis. However, the practice's response to the complaint provided a full explanation, apologies where necessary and also the offer to meet with Ms C to discuss the matter. Although we upheld this aspect of this complaint, we did not consider that there was anything more that we could reasonably expect the practice to do as a result of the complaint and so did not make any recommendations.

In relation to Ms C's complaint about the attitude of the GP, we noted that the practice acknowledged that there was an initial difficult telephone conversation and the GP apologised for this and for the way in which they came across to Ms C. On balance, in the absence of evidence to confirm exactly what was said and, as importantly, the way in which it was said, we were unable to uphold this aspect of Ms C’s complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201004700 as a PDF (14.39 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving A Medical Practice, Lothian NHS Board

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201101588 01 Mar 2012 Mr C attended the practice for an appointment with his GP. During the consultation, he said that the GP told … Not Upheld
201101695 01 Jan 2012 Mr C complained that his GP failed to diagnose rotator cuff syndrome (damage or dysfunction to one of the rotator … Not Upheld
201100473 01 Dec 2011 Mr C complained on behalf of his daughter (Miss A) who attended her medical practice about a rash on her … Not Upheld
201101184 01 Nov 2011 Mrs C raised a number of concerns about the conduct of a nurse at the medical practice she attended during … Partly Upheld
201003446 01 Aug 2011 Mr C complained about the actions of a nurse at his medical practice - for example, that she did not … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation