Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Lothian NHS Board

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201004338 Sector Health Category clinical treatment / diagnosis Decided 01 August 2012

View NHS Lothian scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr and Mrs C complained that, before starting in vitro fertilisation (IVF) treatment, a hospital gave them inaccurate statistical information about relevant IVF success rates applicable to Mrs C.

The couple said that they followed medical advice and undertook IVF treatment in the knowledge that they had been told that due to Mrs C's age, achieving fertilisation might be more challenging. They said that a clinician had advised that as there were no underlying health issues preventing conception, there remained around a 15 percent chance of success.

Mr and Mrs C said that the IVF treatment resulted in one successful embryo transfer. However, the next day Mrs C became unwell, and the transfer failed. The couple complained that the care and treatment Mrs C received was inadequate. They said that staff failed them; that care procedures were lacking; and that staff misled prospective parents.

We took advice from our medical adviser, who considered all the facts and relevant information and guidance. After careful consideration, we decided that there was no evidence that clinical staff had provided inaccurate information to Mr and Mrs C before IVF treatment began. We also considered that the actions of the ward's out-of-hours service staff were appropriate and adequate.

We also looked at how the board handled Mr and Mrs C's complaint and found that they had appropriately addressed all the issues raised.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201004338 as a PDF (17.21 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Lothian NHS Board

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202404449 01 Jan 2026 C complained about the care that their adult child (A) received from the prison healthcare team and particularly a failure … Upheld
202304800 01 Mar 2025 C complained that the board failed to provide reasonable personal care and treatment to their sibling (A). A was admitted … Upheld
202304367 01 Dec 2024 C complained on behalf of their spouse (A) about the standard of care and treatment received in the months before … Partly Upheld
202005296 01 May 2022 C complained that there had been an unreasonable delay in their late parent (A) receiving a prescription of antibiotics following … Upheld
202002582 01 Jan 2021 C complained about the clinical care provided to their child (A) by the board, specifically, that a Chiari malformation (where … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation