Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

North Ayrshire Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201003868 Sector Local Government Category Neighbour disputes and anti-social behaviour Decided 01 August 2011

View North Tyneside Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Mr C complained that the council failed to carry out effective risk assessments when deciding to house a vulnerable adult in accommodation next door to his mother-in-law, Mrs A. He was of the view that the council also failed to deal with reports of anti-social behaviour by their tenant and by visitors to his home. Mr C also said that the council failed to provide any support to Mrs A following a fire at the neighbour's home and also failed to offer to pay for her insurance excess. Following our examination of the case we did not find evidence to suggest that the council failed to carry out appropriate risk assessments or that the neighbour had been housed in unsuitable accommodation. We also did not uphold the complaint that the council failed to investigate the concerns about anti-social behaviour. We found that the council had explained how Mrs A could make a claim to the council's insurers. We did, however, find that the council failed to offer any support to her after the fire. We considered that providing some support would have been appropriate under the circumstances and we upheld this aspect of the complaint. We recommended that the council apologise to Mrs A for this failing and also consider whether there is a need to introduce a procedure to deal with incidents such as this and to address the potential needs of elderly neighbours.

Recommendations

We recommend that North Ayrshire Council: • provide a further apology to Mrs A for their failure to provide her with support; and • consider whether there is a need to introduce a procedure to deal with incidents such as this and to address the potential needs of elderly neighbours.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201003868 as a PDF (19.02 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving North Ayrshire Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202004623 01 Jun 2024 C complained about the advice received and actions taken by trading standards in relation to concerns that they had reported … Not Upheld
202007741 01 Mar 2023 C complained that the council's response to their reports of anti-social behaviour had been inadequate. C said that their neighbour … Not Upheld
201807397 01 Nov 2020 C complained that the council, as planning authority, failed to provide reasonable justification to discharge two conditions relating to an … Not Upheld
201807030 01 Sep 2020 Mr C complained about the council's communication with him. Mr C owns a flat in a building in which the … Upheld
201900245 01 Aug 2020 Ms C complained about the council's handling of a planning application for a housing development adjacent to her property. Ms … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation