Source · Investigations in the NHS

Independent investigation: Chloe Sutherland (8 mnths), Edinburgh (2015)

Scotland Incident 02 Feb 2015 Subject Chloe Sutherland (8 mnths)

Index summary

Post-natally depressed mother fatally smothers daughter. Unable to access care as baby ‘too old’

Recommendations

13 total
1 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 1

Recommendation · source text
ensure that there is enough flexibility in referral criteria so that women with significant histories who have been seen within the service can be re-referred until the child is one year of age.
1 Addressed to: NHS Board C No Response Published

Link to recommendation 1

Recommendation · source text
Review the remit and staffing of the perinatal mental health service community team to ensure they can work towards meeting the quality standards of the perinatal network.
1 Addressed to: Scottish Government No Response Published

Link to recommendation 1

Recommendation · source text
Priority should be given to establishing a national managed clinical network as recommended in SIGN 127 (2012) which states: 'A national managed clinical network for perinatal mental health should be centrally established in Scotland. The network should be managed by a coordinating board of health professionals, health and social care managers, and service users and carers. The network should: Establish standards for the provision of regional inpatient specialised mother and baby units, community specialised perinatal teams and maternity liaison services. Establish pathways for referral and management of women with, or at risk of, mental illness in pregnancy and the postnatal period. Establish competencies and training resources for health professionals caring for pregnant or postnatal women with, or at risk of, mental illness, at levels appropriate to their need. Ensure that all pregnant and postnatal women with, or at risk of, mental illness have equitable access to advice and care appropriate to their level of need.'
1 Addressed to: Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) Scotland No Response Published

Link to recommendation 1

Recommendation · source text
The RCGP and the Centre for Mental Health in England produced a report, ‘Falling through the gaps’ in 2015.15 This report highlights the role of GPs in disclosure, identification and support of women who develop a mental illness in the perinatal period. The recommendations are equally pertinent to Scotland and we would recommend that the RCGP Scotland make similar recommendations to the Scottish Government. The establishment of a managed clinical network would be well placed to lead on and advise how these recommendations could be implemented.
2 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 2

Recommendation · source text
Ensure that there are clear pathways to access specialist perinatal mental health expertise within their board area, including pathways for urgent assessment by local mental health teams as appropriate.
2 Addressed to: NHS Board C No Response Published

Link to recommendation 2

Recommendation · source text
Review the PNMHS referral criteria to ensure that there is enough flexibility so that women with significant histories who have been seen within the service can be re-referred until the child is one year of age.
3 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 3

Recommendation · source text
Ensure that specialist perinatal mental health services complete a late pregnancy and early postnatal care plan in late pregnancy (28-32 weeks) for women at high risk of postnatal major mental illness, as detailed in Sign Guideline 127. This should be shared with maternity services, community midwifery team, GP, health visitor, mental health services and the woman herself. All letters should be structured in a way that highlights the risk and management plan at each contact.
4 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 4

Recommendation · source text
Ensure GP systems identify and highlight risks from perinatal mental health service assessments, these are Read12 coded and alerts set up on practice systems including a Key Information Summary (KIS)13 to capture and share information.
5 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 5

Recommendation · source text
Review IT systems and consider the use of electronic referral systems, for example using the SCI gateway system14. Ensure that general practices review and consider improvements to their IT systems. This could include having two PC monitors to allow access to different electronic systems simultaneously. This would allow access to the GP clinical system and document management systems at the same time and reduce the risk of missing important information toggling between two systems on one screen.
6 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 6

Recommendation · source text
Ensure GP practices, particularly large practices, consider identifying a “go-to” GP with a particular interest in perinatal mental health. This may help minimise inconsistencies in the approach and response of different GPs to perinatal mental health issues.
7 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 7

Recommendation · source text
Review the protocols in place between primary care, specialist teams and other agencies to ensure effective communication and information sharing.
8 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 8

Recommendation · source text
Ensure that there is local good practice guidance on discharge planning in keeping with the Service Standards developed by the RCPsych PQN.
9 Addressed to: All joint health and social care bodies No Response Published

Link to recommendation 9

Recommendation · source text
Ensure that patients treated with antidepressants are reviewed in line with NICE and local good practice guidance.

Acceptance status

Per recommendation
No Response Published
13

Total recommendations
13
About this data

Acceptance status records the published response to each recommendation. Acceptance does not establish that an action has been completed.

Independent health investigation reports and reviews commissioned by government or NHS England.

About this investigation

Source & metadata

Independent investigation report. Recommendations and any published response are extracted below.