Source · Investigations in the NHS
An independent investigation into the care and treatment of mental health service users (F and Maureen) in County Durham: Published 6 September 2017
North East and Yorkshire
Published 06 Sep 2017
Trust Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust
This is the independent investigation into the care and treatment of mental health service users (F and Maureen) in County Durham. F and Maureen were patients on Picktree Ward, a mental health service for older people (MHSOP) ward in the Bowes Lyon Unit at Lanchester Road Hospital, County Durham, provided by Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust. On 19 May 2015, an incident occurred between Maureen and F which resulted in F pushing Maureen from behind resulting in her falling to the gro
Acceptance status
Accepted
7
No Response Published
2
Total recommendations
9
About this investigation
Recommendations
1
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should assure itself that the findings and observations of patients when admitted to MHSOP wards leads to accurate care planning and appropriate interventions.
There are clear processes and procedures in place on MHSOP wards which ensure that findings from patients’ assessments are clearly linked to planned care.
a)5 wards are piloting a refreshed Frailty CLiP (including falls). Full roll out is planned by the end of December 2017.
b)The Behaviours that Challenge CLiP is being implemented on all MHSOP wards
c)Improved MDT Care Planning in the electronic record is being developed with IT support.
d) Dietitian colleagues to deliver training in use of SANSI tool (to replace MUST) across all wards – when the tool is ACD D&D 1 incorporated into PARIS
e) Specialty department specific harm support minimisation training e-learning module will be available to ward to ward staff.
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)31st December 2017 b)31st December 2017 c)Progress is dependent on IT work schedule d)Progress is dependent on IT work schedule e)Progress is dependent on training department
PROGRESS July 2017 Pilot in progress July 2017 Principles agreed Training records Training records
2
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should review management of aggression guidance and the clinical link pathway for Behaviours that Challenge in Mental Health Services for Older People wards to ensure that explicit guidance in how to manage an incident is an outcome of …
Read more
View response
There are clear processes and procedures in place on MHSOP wards which ensure that findings from patients’ assessments (in relation to aggression) are clearly linked to planned care.
a)Since the index incident, the Behaviours that Challenge CLiP has been reviewed and updated to include new National guidance and updated NICE guidance.
b)The revised CLiP includes the development of a Behaviour Support Plan – Ward Managers are tasked with ensuring that these are developed where necessary
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)Complete b)28th February 2018
PROGRESS Complete MHSOP findings from the Trust-wide Clinical audit
3
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should ensure that MHSOP wards fully comply with the policy on recording observations.
View response
MHSOP can demonstrate adherence to the Supportive Engagement and Observations Procedure
a)SBARD highlighting the recording requirements from the procedure to be circulated through MHSOP
b) SBARD to include instructions regarding the need to give a rationale for rare circumstances where the procedure cannot be followed.
c) QuAGs have considered the use of zonal observation as per the procedure
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)30th September 2017 b)30th September 2017 c)31st October 2017
PROGRESS Modern matrons to randomly spot-check recording records of patients requiring Supportive engagement and provide reports to SDG in December 2017 and June 2018
4
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should ensure that all relevant policies and procedures are updated whenever new guidance from NICE is issued.
View response
All polices are updated according to Policy guidelines
As part of the policy and procedure review process the Policy Lead is responsible for undertaking review of the evidence base which includes NICE Guidance where relevant. This process is documented within the Governance of Policies and Procedures Policy document CORP-0001-v5: The Executive Management Team has delegated authority from the Trust Board to ratify all Trust policies and procedures. Minor amendments have been made to this policy following the homicide review recommendations to further strengthen stipulated Policy Lead responsibilities in relation to updating the evidence base of relevant policies and procedures.
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION Complete
PROGRESS Complete
5
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should develop a programme of increased awareness of the need to accurately report incidents with the MHSOP wards, and assure itself that incidents are being accurately reported.
View response
MHSOP can demonstrate that clear communication regarding incident reporting has been shared with ward staff
a)SBARD to be written and circulated within MHSOP
b) review of recorded incidents, trends including low reporting is a function of QuAGs
c) ward report-outs include discussion of incidents that have occurred and confirm reporting has taken place
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)30th September 2017 b)31st December 2017 c)31st December 2017
PROGRESS SDG minutes QuAG minutes QuAG minutes, and QuAG reports to LMGB and SDG Modern matron spot-checks of daily report-outs
6
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should assure itself that MHSOP wards are now following its own best practice guidance with regards to Behaviours that Challenge in dementia.
View response
We can provide evidence that the CLiP is implemented on all MHSOP wards.
a)continue the roll-out of the CLiP
b) audit compliance with the requirements of the CLiP
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)31st December 2017 b)28th February 2018
PROGRESS SDG and QuAG minutes Audit report
7
The Trust
Accepted
Recommendation
The Trust should assure itself that assessments of risks in elderly patients are completed thoroughly and accurately, incorporating all aspects of relevant medical history, and which then lead to appropriate interventions to mitigate these risks.
View response
MHSOP can demonstrate clear risk assessments which are linked to care plans
a) Narrative summary of risks has been introduced with an MHSOP specific crib sheet
b) MHSOP harm minimisation training will incorporate medical history and the requirement to develop linked care plans
c) the Care Planning development workstream is exploring electronic ways to link risks identified to care planning
TARGET DATE FOR COMPLETION a)Complete b)Progress is dependent on training department support c)Progress is dependent on IT work schedule
PROGRESS Complete Safety Summary Compilation - Specialty Crib MHSOP.pdf Training content & ACD D&D training records Notes from the Nurse working group / reports from PARIS development team
8
NHS Durham Dales Easington & Sedgefield Clinical Commissioning Group and the Trust
Pending
Recommendation
NHS Durham Dales Easington & Sedgefield Clinical Commissioning Group and the Trust should work together to ensure that they fully implement the NICE Clinical guideline [CG146], Osteoporosis: assessing the risk of fragility fracture correctly identifying all patients at risk of …
Read more
View response
NHS Durham Dales Easington & Sedgefield Clinical Commissioning Group and the Trust should work together to ensure that they fully implement the NICE Clinical guideline [CG146], Osteoporosis: assessing the risk of fragility fracture correctly identifying all patients at risk of fragile fracture on respective caseloads
9
NHS Durham Dales, Sedgefield and Easington CCG, NHS North Durham CCG, Tees, Esk & Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust and North East Ambulance Service
Pending
Recommendation
NHS Durham Dales, Sedgefield and Easington CCG, NHS North Durham CCG, Tees, Esk & Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust and North East Ambulance Service should regularly and collectively review all deaths of patients …
Read more
View response
NHS Durham Dales, Sedgefield and Easington CCG, NHS North Durham CCG, Tees, Esk & Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust and North East Ambulance Service should regularly and collectively review all deaths of patients transferred from MHSOP wards to A&E with suspected fragility fractures to fully identify opportunities for system improvements to reduce premature deaths.