National Audit Office

Modernising ageing digital services

Published 6 Dec 2022 Value for Money 6 recommendations

Recommendations 6

6 accepted. 5 implemented.

Recommendation 1

Response: Accepted · Delivery: implemented, Q4 2023-24 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point a

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
Defra should: a) develop an overall strategic digital vision to apply to the whole Defra Group and put in place governance and management structures to ensure that digital and data considerations are at the heart of the business transformation process. This should include providing a stronger steer on what design and architecture are needed to support business transformation to avoid opportunities for standardisation and rationalisation being missed

Recommendation 2

Response: Accepted · Delivery: implemented, Q4 2024-25 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point b

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
b) establish the senior leadership needed, for example through the appointment of a chief data officer, to develop common data models and standards that can be used to support better use of data where there are common capabilities such as grant payments

Recommendation 3

Response: Accepted · Delivery: implemented, Q4 2023-24 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point c

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
c) when new applications are being designed and built, ensure that opportunities for re-use across Defra Group are understood and built into the design

Recommendation 4

Response: Accepted · Delivery: implemented, Q2 2024-25 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point d

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
d) develop long-term priorities, timelines and funding requirements that extend beyond the stabilisation phase to maintain the momentum currently driving the Legacy Applications Programme as it progresses into the enhance and
transform phase

Recommendation 5

Response: Accepted · Delivery: implemented, Q3 2023-24 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point e

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
e) carry out an analysis of the reasons recruitment is failing and work with Defra Group HR, the Central Digital and Data Offce and suppliers to develop solutions

Recommendation 6

Response: Accepted · Delivery: not started, Q2 2027-28 (confirmed by the NAO)

Addressed to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs · Page 11, paragraph 24, point f

Recommendation (the NAO's words)
f) develop a better understanding of the additional business and people costs of the continued use of unmodernised digital services, focusing initially on its most used digital services, to help inform investment priorities.