Source · National Audit Office
Business support schemes
Published: 15 Jan 2020
Recommendations: 7
Type: Value for Money
NAO confirmed: 7
Department: Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy
This report examines the Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy’s management of its business support schemes.
Recommendations
| Rec | Recommendation | Addressee | Acceptance | Implementation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
[The] Department should ensure that from March 2020, any new business support scheme:
a) has clear objectives in place from the outset that are measurable and timebound, enabling a scheme’s progress to be assessed;
Ref Page 14, paragraph 21, point a
· Implemented Q4 2020-21
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 2 |
b) considers alternative ways of achieving its objectives, including a meaningful estimate of the value for money of viable alternatives;
Ref Page 14, paragraph 21, point b
· Implemented Q4 2020-21
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 3 |
c) has a monitoring plan that shows how interim measures link to the scheme’s ultimate objectives if these are not immediately measurable; and
Ref Page 14, paragraph 21, point c
· Implemented Q4 2020-21
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 4 |
d) sets out plans for evaluation, including how it will ensure such assessment is supported by robust evidence of the impact against the criteria in its updated evaluation framework.
Ref Page 14, paragraph 21, point d
· Implemented Q4 2020-21
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 5 |
In its management of its overall portfolio of business support schemes, the Department should:
e) coordinate a review of its schemes to determine their strategic fit with the Industrial Strategy and what consequent changes are required by July 2020;
Ref Page 14, paragraph 22, point e
· Implemented Q4 2021-22
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 6 |
f) develop some standard metrics across schemes that have broadly similar aims, to enable better comparison of their effectiveness by May 2020. This should include routine monitoring of businesses’ views; and
Ref Page 14, paragraph 22, point f
· Implemented Q4 2023-24
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
| 7 |
g) monitor schemes' compliance with the good-practice principles of scheme management that we have set out in this report and use this to drive improvements.
Ref Page 14, paragraph 22, point g
· Implemented Q4 2024-25
|
Department for Business and Trade | Accepted | Implemented ✓ NAO |
Public Accounts Committee follow-up
The Public Accounts Committee examined this NAO report and published its own recommendations. The government responds to PAC recommendations via Treasury Minutes.
20 Nov 2021
Public Accounts C…
Twenty-Sixth Report - Lessons from Greensill Capital: accreditation to business support schemes
— 15 recommendations
· parliament.uk