Source · Recommendations & oversight

National Audit Office

NAO value-for-money reports examining the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of government spending. Recommendations are tracked against government responses and, where a PAC hearing followed, linked to the committee's own recommendations and Treasury Minute responses.

2,824 reports 2,175 recommendations 1,827 confirmed by NAO 61% implementation rate

Reports

2,824 matching reports · newest published first

Follow-up on alternative higher education providers

Published 18 Oct 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

The Department is exerting stronger oversight and sanctioning under-performing providers but there remain issues to resolve, such as more timely identification of underperformance and ineligible payments.

Care Quality Commission regulating health and social care

Published 13 Oct 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Although the Commission has improved as an organisation, it needs to overcome some persistent issues with the timeliness of some of its regulation activities if it is to sustain further improvement.

The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority’s Magnox contract

Published 11 Oct 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

The NDA’s fundamental failures in the Magnox contract procurement raise serious questions about its understanding of procurement regulations and its ability to manage large, complex procurements.

Homelessness

Published 13 Sep 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

Homelessness has increased across all measures since 2010, with many local authorities now seeing it as a risk to their financial sustainability.

Retaining and developing the teaching workforce

Published 12 Sep 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Education

Schools, especially secondary schools, face real challenges in retaining and developing their teachers. National data suggest progress but mask significant local variation.

Investigation into the management of the Libor Fund

Published 8 Sep 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

The Government has committed £933 million from the Libor Fund, but cannot yet confirm that all the money has been used as intended.

Managing the costs of clinical negligence in trusts

Published 7 Sep 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The cost of clinical negligence in trusts is significant and rising fast, placing increasing financial pressure on an already stretched system.

The first sale of shares in Royal Bank of Scotland

Published 14 Jul 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

The first sale of government shares in the Royal Bank of Scotland in August 2015 was well planned and organised and represented value for money.

The Customs Declaration Service

Published 13 Jul 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

HM Revenue and Customs

HMRC has made progress in developing the new customs system, which was part of its existing programme, but it may need to be ready much earlier than originally planned if there is no agreement extending …

The new generation electronic monitoring programme

Published 12 Jul 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Justice

The case for a huge expansion of electronic monitoring using GPS was unproven, but the Ministry of Justice pursued an overly ambitious and high risk strategy anyway. Ultimately it has not delivered.

Progress in setting up combined authorities

Published 6 Jul 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

For combined authorities to deliver real progress they will need to demonstrate that they can drive economic growth and contribute to public sector reform.

Investigation into NHS continuing healthcare funding

Published 5 Jul 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

Funding for ongoing health care is a complex and highly sensitive area, which can affect some of the most vulnerable people in society and those that care for them.

Department for Work and Pensions Accounts 2016-17

Published 4 Jul 2017 Financial Audit No recommendations indexed

Department for Work and Pensions

The Comptroller and Auditor General, Amyas Morse, has qualified his audit opinion on the regularity of the 2016-17 accounts of the Department for Work and Pensions. This is owing to the high level of fraud …

Online Fraud

Published 30 Jun 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Home Office

Online fraud is now the most commonly experienced crime in England and Wales, but has been overlooked by government, law enforcement and industry.

Mental health in prisons

Published 29 Jun 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care · Ministry of Justice

Government does not know how many people in prison have a mental illness, how much it is spending on mental health in prisons or whether it is achieving its objectives. It is therefore hard to …

Response and delivery evidence

2,175 recommendations tracked

Across the NAO recommendation corpus. Response, implementation and NAO confirmation are separate measures; the categories below overlap.

Status Recommendations Share
Implemented 1,320 61%
Accepted 1,718 79%
Partially accepted 200 9%
Work in progress 503 23%
Rejected 41 2%
Confirmed by NAO follow-up 1,827 84%
Methodology: status determined from departmental responses, Treasury Minute responses, PAC follow-up hearings, and NAO own progress tracking.

Departments named in NAO reports

Departments named in NAO reports · all years
Department of Health and Social Care (126 reports) HM Treasury (95 reports) Cabinet Office (88 reports) Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (81 reports) Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (76 reports) HM Revenue and Customs (74 reports) Department for Work and Pensions (66 reports) Ministry of Defence (63 reports) Department for Education (63 reports) Department for Transport (62 reports) Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (56 reports) Devolved administrations (56 reports) Home Office (53 reports) Ministry of Justice (39 reports) Department for Culture, Media & Sport (30 reports)