Source · HSSIB Patient Safety Investigation

Safety risk of air embolus associated with central venous catheters used for haemodialysis treatment

Published 30 March 2023 Launched 16 March 2022 Published HSIB Legacy
Medical devices

This investigation aims to improve patient safety by supporting healthcare staff in the safe use of central venous catheters to access a patient’s blood supply.

View on HSSIB ↗  · Download Report PDF ↗

Summary

3 recommendations 4 observations 2 actions 3 of 3 responded

Safety Recommendations

3 total
R/2023/225 GMC
HSIB recommends that the General Medical Council engages with relevant stakeholders to amend the procedure for taking blood cultures in its ‘Practical skills and procedures’ guidance, making clear that the procedure relates to taking blood from a peripheral site, so mitigating the risks to patient safety associated with central lines.
The GMC engaged stakeholders, communicated the need for the amendment to medical schools, and outlined a plan to publish updated guidance by August 2023, confirming local implementation by medical schools by December 2024.
Response received 23 June 2023
We sent a letter (15 May 2023) to the deans of all UK medical schools, co-signed by the Medical Schools Council and the UK Foundation Programme Office, to explain that this amendment is needed to mitigate risks to patients, and we will therefore implement this recommendation as soon as is practically possible. To support this, we requested all medical schools respond to a set of questions that would enable us to determine an appropriate amendment and timelines for the change to be implemented locally by medical schools. We understand that local implementation by medical schools will involve communicating the amendment to educators and learners, as well as updating learning materials and documentation. This letter also outlined our plans to use the quality assurance self-assessment questionnaires medical schools complete annually to confirm that the amendment has been implemented locally. In response to this letter, we have received strong support for making an amendment to the list and for this to have been implemented locally by medical schools in time for the 2023-2024 academic year. A second letter will be sent to all UK medical schools confirming the specific amendment that will be made and requesting this is locally implemented in time for the new academic year. We will then publish an updated version of the Outcomes for graduates - Practical skills and procedures (2019) on our website and communicate this through relevant channels. Actions planned to deliver safety recommendation: GMC to write to all UK medical schools confirming the amendment it will make to the practical skills and procedures list and its expectations for when medical schools should implement this locally, by July 2023. GMC to publish updated Outcomes for graduates – Practical skills and procedures on its website and communicate the change through relevant channels, by August 2023. GMC to confirm the amendment has been implemented locally by all medical schools through the annual self-assessment questionnaires all medical schools complete, by October 2023 - December 2024. Response received on 23 June 2023.
R/2023/226 GMC
HSIB recommends that the General Medical Council, supported by the Medical Schools Council, revises ‘Achieving good medical practice’ to include guidance for medical students on how to handle uncertainty in clinical settings, including challenging a culture, or an expectation, that a learner undertake unfamiliar tasks to gain competencies without appropriate supervision or support.
The GMC, with MSC, will review and update 'Achieving good medical practice' by Q1 2024 to include guidance on handling uncertainty and challenging unsafe tasks. They will also use quality assurance and a student competition to promote awareness.
Response received 23 June 2023
A new version of Good medical practice (2013), which describes the professional behaviours expected of all doctors registered with the GMC, is to be published imminently. This will enable us, in conjunction with the Medical Schools Council (MSC), to begin our review of Achieving good medical practice: guidance for medical students (2016), which shows how the principles and values of Good medical practice apply to medical students. Through this work we will determine how best to include the type of guidance specified in this safety recommendation. We have sent a letter (15 May 2023) to the deans of all UK medical schools, co-signed by the Medical Schools Council, setting out our plan to have updated this document and implemented this safety recommendation by the end of Quarter 1 2024. This letter also outlined plans to use the quality assurance self-assessment questionnaires medical schools complete annually to explore questions in relation to the safeguards that are in place for medical students on clinical placements. We will also use the next medical student professionalism competition, which we run with the MSC, to focus on the importance of learners always working within their competence. This will promote awareness of this issue. Actions planned to deliver safety recommendation: GMC and MSC to review Achieving good medical practice: guidance for medical students, by August 2023 - April 2024. GMC to publish updated Achieving good medical practice: guidance for medical students, by April 2024. The GMC and MSC will run the next student professionalism competition on topic of students working within their competence, by June - October 2023. The GMC will explore questions around safeguards for medical students on clinical placements through annual quality assurance self-assessment questionnaires, by October 2023 - December 2024. Response received on 23 June 2023.
R/2023/227 Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency
HSIB recommends that the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency amends its 2022 ‘Dialysis guidance’ to include the safety risk of air emboli associated with unclamped haemodialysis catheters.
The MHRA has updated its 2022 ‘Dialysis Guidance’ to include the safety risk of air embolus associated with unclamped haemodialysis catheters and emphasize clamping/capping, completing the action in Q2 2023.
Response received 18 July 2023
We have considered HSIB’s investigation report relating to the safety risk of air embolus associated with central venous catheters used for haemodialysis treatment and noted the specific recommendation made to us. Air ingress due to unclamped catheters is an avoidable safety risk and further communication may help reducing the number of occurrences; we have therefore updated the MHRA Dialysis Guidance to raise awareness of the importance of clamping and capping central venous catheters. Action carried out to deliver safety recommendation response: Update of the MHRA Dialysis Guidance (2022) in quarter 2, 2023, to include risk of air embolus associated with unclamped haemodialysis catheters. Response received on 18 July 2023.

Safety Observations

4 total
Observation 1 Observation It may be beneficial for manufacturers of haemodialysis catheters to develop an engineering solution to maintain a sealed system upon disconnection, thereby reducing the risk of an air embolism.
Observation 2 Observation It may be beneficial to consider how junior doctors can be supported to work safely within their level of competence and feel empowered to decline tasks they are not competent to undertake, with specific reference to the safety risks associated with accessing haemodialysis catheters if not trained and competent.
Observation 3 Observation It may be beneficial to explore the design of a visual alert which prompts healthcare professionals to the increased safety risks associated with in situ haemodialysis catheters and the access to this medical device by staff specifically trained in their use.
Observation 4 Observation It may be beneficial if the approach outlined in the White Paper published by the National Infusion and Vascular Access Society in 2022 was adopted for wider bore lines such as haemodialysis catheters. This is in relation to a standardised structure and approach for the NHS to deliver vascular access services in every hospital.

Safety Actions

2 total
Action 1 Action The Medical Schools Council has shared the communication with all medical schools that medical students are not required to demonstrate competence in undertaking blood sampling from a central line, and if part of their current competency requirements, they are to withdraw this requirement going forwards.
Action 2 Action The Association of Anaesthetists has agreed to include content on catheter-related air embolism in the updated ‘Safe vascular access guidelines’, based on the HSIB investigation findings and safety recommendations.