About this page. This page summarises a Domestic Homicide Review published in the Home Office DHR Library. The full report is available at the source link below. Victim and perpetrator names are not included in extracted summaries on this page.
Source · Domestic Homicide Review

Sheffield review

CSP: Sheffield Published: September 2023 Year of death: 2016 Extracted: 30 recs

Statutory domestic homicide review under section 9 of the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004. Source: Home Office DHR Library.

Original review (PDF) ↗ Source: Home Office DHR Library

Summary AI-generated

Verify against the full report at the source link
The report identifies systemic failures in inter-agency information sharing, risk assessment, and professional curiosity across police, health, social care, and education. Key concerns include treating domestic abuse incidents in isolation, inadequate record-keeping, and missed opportunities to identify and respond to the victim's vulnerability and mental health issues.

Home Office classifications

40 tags

Source-supplied classifications used by the Home Office to catalogue this review.

  • Victim - physical disability
  • Victim - mental ill health
  • Victim - depression
  • Victim - self harm
  • Victim - suicide attempts
  • Victim - serious or life limiting illness
  • Victim - had been a victim of an abuser before
  • Victim - immigration involvement
  • Children - under 18 shared parental responsibility (between perpetrators)
  • Perpetrator - case heard in court
  • Perpetrator - issued life sentence
  • Perpetrator - known to agencies as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to police as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to social services as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to health services as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to mental health services as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to other educational institution as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to others as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to friends as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to family as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Aggravating factors - separation
  • Aggravating factors - coercive or controlling behaviour
  • Aggravating factors - psychological or emotional abuse
  • Aggravating factors - physical abuse
  • Aggravating factors - economic abuse
  • DHR process - family contributed to dhr
  • DHR process - family supported by expert specialist advocate
  • DHR process - police recommendations
  • DHR process - social services recommendations
  • DHR process - health services recommendations
  • DHR process - other educational institution recommendations
  • DHR process - community safety partnership recommendations
  • DHR process - technology systems recommendation themes
  • DHR process - identification of risk recommendation themes
  • DHR process - training recommendation themes
  • DHR process - policy recommendation themes
  • DHR process - multi agency working recommendation themes
  • DHR process - record keeping recommendation themes
  • DHR process - awareness raising recommendation themes
  • DHR process - other recommendation themes

Extracted recommendations

30 recommendations pulled from the report · 21 matched to organisations in the index

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Sheffield First Safer and Sustainable Communities Partnership (SFSSCP)

The Sheffield First Safer and Sustainable Communities Partnership (SFSSCP) should request that the community safety partnership that covers the Colchester hospital areas seeks assurance from them that they are implementing their action plan and disseminating learning from this review. This CSP should also ensure the same applies for Essex police.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust

All staff to be made aware of the recommendations within the IMR and the DHR when published.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottinghamshire Police

Where children are recorded on the DASH form, officers should be reminded of the need to obtain their full details including a current address wherever possible. This may require further enquiries and research by the officer submitting the DASH form.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottingham Trent University

When a student states that other agencies are dealing with issues such as those raised in this case either in the Notification of Exceptional Circumstances procedure or via any other contact with the University that our Student Support Services teams do check wherever possible on the information provided that this indeed has been referred to the appropriate agencies to investigate.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust

Domestic abuse training to be explicit that clinical enquiry must be carried out when a patient discloses domestic abuse

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust

There is a clear need to re-enforce record keeping and assessments following contacts with clients evidenced within this review.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottingham CityCare Partnership

City Care Urgent Care Centre will continue to implement clinical enquiry around domestic abuse and will continue to be vigilant to signs of domestic abuse during all contacts with service users.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to GP practices | Nottingham City Clinical Commissioning Group (NCCCG)

The GP practice to develop a protocol for the processing and recording of DART referrals in conjunction with the CCG within a view to this being shared across all City GP practices.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Nottingham City Council Adult Social Care

Standard letter for general DART use outlining correct contact number and resources if deemed safe and appropriate. This can be amended according to need, risk and safety aspects.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Sheffield First Safer and Sustainable Communities Partnership (SFSSCP)

The Sheffield First Safer and Sustainable Communities Partnership (SFSSCP) should request that the relevant community safety partnerships within Nottinghamshire seek assurance from the agencies below that they are implementing their action plan and disseminating learning from this review and specifically request:

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust

Specific training is undertaken on recognising and safeguarding patients who may be victims or perpetrators of domestic abuse in identified high risk areas on admission to CHUFT. This must include A&E, EAU and Maternity.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Nottinghamshire Police

DASU staff are reminded of the requirement to consider safeguarding referrals for children recorded on the DASH form irrespective of the policing area in which they currently reside.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust

Domestic abuse training to be explicit that even if there is already an agency involved that a DASH risk assessment should be completed and relevant referrals made

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to GP practices

The GP Practice to change its policy on redacting third part information from DART referrals in line with National IG good practice Guidelines.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Nottingham City Council Adult Social Care

Explanation should be provided as to why contact is not made via telephone and if the safety of speaking via the telephone is questionable, then evidence of this must be documented.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2i

Addressed to Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust

Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust that they are delivering clear domestic abuse training to its staff so that a clinical enquiry is carried out when a patient discloses domestic abuse. This training must make it clear that even if there is already an agency involved then a DASH RIC should still be completed and the relevant referrals made.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2ii

Addressed to Nottingham City Council Adult Social Care

Nottingham City Council Adult Social Care should ensure that the standard letter for general DART use outlines the correct contact number and the available resources that are deemed safe and appropriate. This can always be amended according to need, risk and safety aspects. There is in place a clear protocol for record keeping which would cover when phone calls will be deemed unsafe. The records need to document why unsafe and clear rationale for this. An audit of records should assure the CSP that the recording policy is being adhered to.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2iii

Addressed to NHS Nottingham City Clinical Commissioning Group (NCCCG)

NCCCG should work with GP practices to develop a protocol that can be used by them when processing and recording DART referrals.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2iv

Addressed to Nottinghamshire Police

Nottinghamshire Police ensures that where children are recorded on the DASH RIC, Officers should be reminded of the need to obtain their full details including a current address wherever possible. This may require further enquiries and research by the Officer submitting the DASH RIC. This includes the requirement to consider safeguarding referrals for children recorded on the DASH RIC irrespective of the policing area in which they currently reside. Nottinghamshire Police Officers should be reminded that if a victim has moved out of Nottinghamshire the person with that information must ensure that the new Policing Area and Command Unit are informed. The new address should be provided and the Policing Area appraised of the abuse and risk category of the victim.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2v

Addressed to Nottingham Trent University

Nottingham Trent University is making sure that their staff use professional curiosity when a student informs them that they are subject to DA and checks other agencies are actually dealing with the abuse. Particularly if a student subsequently drops out of their course / is unable to be contacted.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to Sheffield First Safer and Sustainable Communities Partnership (SFSSCP)

In order to help to disseminate learning the SFSSCP should write to the Home Office to ask them for guidance on what good practice is currently happening across the UK in relation to intervention programmes that are delivered to perpetrators. In this case it is felt that a programme could have been a preventative factor however guidance is needed on commissioning such a programme and how to achieve the maximum effect. The SFSSCP should share findings with the other CSP’s involved in this DHR.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust

Urgent review of the documentation in ED and EAU should be undertaken to ensure routine domestic abuse enquiry on admission. This routine enquiry should mirror the process already established within Maternity services at CHUFT where domestic abuse information is routinely and explicitly obtained from the patient.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to Nottinghamshire Police

Officers should be reminded that if a victim has moved out of Nottinghamshire the officer with that information must ensure that the new force and command unit are informed. The new address should be provided and the new force appraised of circumstances of the abuse and risk category of the victim.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust

Additional training to be delivered to GUM staff to include nursing assistants.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to Nottingham City Clinical Commissioning Group (NCCCG)

The Nottingham City CCG to issue guidance on the recording of third party information on clinical records to all GP practices in the city.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 4

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust

Staff must ensure that GP details are routinely checked and documented on admission to CHUFT.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 4

Addressed to GP practices

GP practice to develop a clear protocol in relation to the contacting of students following the disclosure of deliberate overdose/self-harm

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 5

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust | Essex Police | MARAC

CHUFT liaises with Essex Police and MARAC to develop a robust procedure for information sharing. Any information should then be shared within the organisation as appropriate including central alerts on the patient information system (Portal) regarding the risk to an individual.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 5

Addressed to Nottingham City Clinical Commissioning Group (NCCCG)

Nottingham City CCG to issue information to GP Practices to remind them of the links between mental health, domestic violence and suicide.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 6

Addressed to Colchester Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust

Victims or perpetrators who disclose domestic abuse should be offered the opportunity to speak to a member of staff from EDAAP currently based within CHUFT.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗