About this page. This page summarises a Domestic Homicide Review published in the Home Office DHR Library. The full report is available at the source link below. Victim and perpetrator names are not included in extracted summaries on this page.
Source · Domestic Homicide Review

South Gloucestershire review

CSP: South Gloucestershire Published: May 2023 Year of death: 2015 Extracted: 44 recs

Statutory domestic homicide review under section 9 of the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004. Source: Home Office DHR Library.

Original review (PDF) ↗ Source: Home Office DHR Library

Summary AI-generated

Verify against the full report at the source link
The review identified concerns regarding the victim's vulnerability due to drug use, mental health, and sex work, alongside challenges in agency engagement due to a chaotic lifestyle. It highlighted issues in recognising domestic abuse in a same-sex male relationship and the need for improved cross-agency information sharing and tailored support.

Home Office classifications

32 tags

Source-supplied classifications used by the Home Office to catalogue this review.

  • Victim - alcohol misuse
  • Victim - substance misuse
  • Victim - housing issues
  • Victim - mental ill health
  • Victim - depression
  • Victim - self harm
  • Victim - had been a victim of an abuser before
  • Victim - referred to marac at any time
  • Victim - case heard at marac before homicide
  • Perpetrator - alcohol misuse
  • Perpetrator - known to agencies as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to police as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to social services as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Perpetrator - known to housing services as a domestic abuse perpetrator
  • Aggravating factors - coercive or controlling behaviour
  • Aggravating factors - psychological or emotional abuse
  • Aggravating factors - physical abuse
  • DHR process - family contributed to dhr
  • DHR process - family consulted about terms of reference
  • DHR process - family received draft report
  • DHR process - family attended dhr panel
  • DHR process - police recommendations
  • DHR process - social services recommendations
  • DHR process - health services recommendations
  • DHR process - community safety partnership recommendations
  • DHR process - technology systems recommendation themes
  • DHR process - identification of risk recommendation themes
  • DHR process - training recommendation themes
  • DHR process - policy recommendation themes
  • DHR process - multi agency working recommendation themes
  • DHR process - awareness raising recommendation themes
  • DHR process - other recommendation themes

Extracted recommendations

44 recommendations pulled from the report · 16 matched to organisations in the index

Recommendation 1

Addressed to Government Equalities Office

Enhancement or amendment to Equality Act 2010 to ensure the consistency of monitoring of protected characteristics and consistency of training.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 2

Addressed to Avon and Somerset Constabulary | South Gloucestershire Council

Where a victim may have links or associations across Local Authority boundaries, that the MARAC and its participating agencies ensure that the MARAC in the relevant adjoining area and organisations in that area are informed and invited to share information.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 3

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council

All agencies taking part in this Review and organisations which are members of the South Gloucestershire and Bristol Community Safety Partnerships have role commensurate Equalities training including competencies in working with Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans communities.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 4

Addressed to South Gloucestershire and Bristol Community Safety Partnerships

South Gloucestershire and Bristol Community Safety Partnerships will assist those none specialist organisations that do not have appropriate domestic abuse policies to introduce fit for purpose domestic abuse policies.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 5

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council | Bristol City Council

South Glos and Bristol substance misuse services to ensure communication between treatment providers and pharmacies- with particular focus on information being shared on the initiation and cessation of opiate substitution therapy prescriptions.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 6

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council | Bristol City Council

Commissioners to require agencies successful in tendering for contracts to have effective policies around domestic abuse that recognise issues relating to LGBT community

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 7

Addressed to Avon and Somerset Constabulary

The method of making contact with a vulnerable victim should be considered extremely carefully, particularly if it is known that the perpetrator controls access to/use of a mobile telephone.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 8

Addressed to Avon and Somerset Constabulary

Where unusual/less frequently occurring cases requiring support present themselves, Lighthouse staff should be encouraged to seek support by discussing the case with a supervisor before making referrals/deciding upon the method of communicating with the victim.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 9

Addressed to Avon and Somerset Constabulary

Avon and Somerset Constabulary should seek new partnerships with charities working with men, including men and sex working men who are at risk of exploitation/abuse from their partners, including risk of DA.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 10

Addressed to Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust

Learning from this incident to be shared with the BSDAS teams, particularly in relation to more inquisitive questioning about potential risk issues.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 11

Addressed to Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust

BDP and BSDAS to review procedures for transferring service users from shared care to BSDAS specialist prescribing, to explore whether there are ways of more effectively facilitating service users attendance and engagement with the new team.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 12

Addressed to Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust

BSDAS to explore accessing Illy electronic case records for continuity of care purposes for service users attending South Gloucester Drug and Alcohol services.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 13

Addressed to Bristol Drugs Project

BDP will establish a centralised system of recording where issues pertaining to Domestic Abuse are recognised.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 16

Addressed to Developing Health and Independence

Triage risk assessment tool to be reviewed and revised risk assessment tool agreed, revised risk assessment tool adopted

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 19

Addressed to Developing Health and Independence

Undertake a ‘lessons’ learnt meeting with the team in relation to this case, to include the lessons learnt above, plus potential assumptions about risk, boundaries of role in supporting client in relation to person in treatment i.e. where they are not directly working with the person in treatment

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 22

Addressed to North Bristol NHS Trust

Safeguarding training to be reviewed to include reinforcement that DA can and does occur in same sex partnerships

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 23

Addressed to North Bristol NHS Trust

Information sharing at MARAC to be audited to ensure information is shared when it is in the possession of NBT

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 24

Addressed to St. Mungo's Broadway

Amend initial assessment forms to assess equality and diversity needs at the start of the assessment process when a client first enters the service. As required using guidance from the Diversity Trust.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 25

Addressed to Sirona Care and Health

Sirona managers responsible for the MIU to provide additional training for staff to ensure that the full checklist of safeguarding questions (including questions about mental health) are completed in every case.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 26

Addressed to Sirona Care and Health

The Safeguarding Lead for Sirona to meet with MIU staff as a matter of urgency and provide additional bespoke training on safeguarding and domestic violence issues.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 27

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

To discuss the outcomes of this report with all Senior Practitioners.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 28

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

To ensure all correspondence from MARAC is copied to Senior Practitioners.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 29

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

To ensure that any post relating to possible risk is sent 1st class.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 30

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

To devise scripts when contacting Service User by phone who may have an abuser present.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 31

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

To ensure that all cases with potential domestic abuse are prioritised and utilising the DASH risk assessment where appropriate within adult safeguarding.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 32

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

Ensure all recommendations are followed and reviewed regularly in Supervisions

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 33

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

Contact with named police officers and discussion with alternative colleagues when not available

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 34

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

Building on DASH risk assessment completed by other agencies to ensure a more comprehensive assessment of risk and consistent approach

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 35

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Council: Children, Adults and Health

Adherence to agreed time scales for actions and feedback, avoidance of drift

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 36

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

The MARAC Operating Protocol should be reviewed to ensure it is fit for purpose and ensure confidence that it is a process not a meeting. § Best practice in terms of safe phone contact with victims (e.g for those who have stated their phone is monitored by the perpetrator, or for those in same sex relationships where it is likely to be difficult to confirm the person you are speaking to).

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 37

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

The MARAC Steering Group should review the standing invite list for MARAC on a quarterly basis for accuracy and appropriateness. In addition, a process should be agreed in terms of responsibility for identifying and including additional agencies in any MARAC case

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 38

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

The MARAC Steering Group should review best practice in terms of MARAC Minutes and make any necessary amendments to the South Gloucestershire process / template as required.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 39

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

Increase the time between the referral deadline and circulation of the MARAC agenda to allow time to seek further information and identify additional agencies to attend. E.g. In the case of the victim – an appropriate method of contact for him and liaison with relevant Bristol agencies.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 40

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

The MARAC Referral Form should be reviewed to ensure it is fit for purpose and reflects best practice.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 41

Addressed to South Gloucestershire MARAC

The MARAC Steering Group to consider implementing appropriate quality assurance and audit functions

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 42

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG)

Practices to be encouraged to consider implementing a system of identifying and allocating known drug users to a specific GP who should co-ordinate their care, with flagging of records to indicate which GP they should be directed to.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 43

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG)

Awareness raising and training about the links between mental health and substance misuse and domestic abuse to be reinforced.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗

Recommendation 44

Addressed to South Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG)

Training in recognition of domestic abuse in men to be made available to all GPs.

Verified wording from the published review · Original review (PDF) ↗