Publish Exercise Reports and Lessons
COVID-19 Inquiry · Module 1: Resilience and Preparedness · Issued 18 July 2024 · Addressed to: Cabinet Office
Source — verbatim from the inquiry
●Inquiry recommendation
For all civil emergency exercises, the governments of the UK, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should each (unless there are reasons of national security for not doing so): publish an exercise report summarising the findings, lessons and recommendations, within three months of the conclusion of the exercise; publish an action plan setting out the specific steps that will be taken in response to the report's findings, and by which entity, within six months of the conclusion of the exercise; and keep exercise reports, action plans, and emergency plans and guidance from across the UK in a single, UK-wide online archive, accessible to all involved in emergency preparedness, resilience and response.
COVID-19 Inquiry, Module 1: Resilience and Preparedness · 18 Jul 2024 Source PDF →
Published evidence summary
Publicly available evidence relating to this recommendation:
- The UK Resilience Academy was launched in April 2025 with an Exercising Hub (Module 1 Implementation Update, Cabinet Office, 8 July 2025).
- A cross-government Lessons Management framework was under development, with guidance recommending publication within 3 months but acknowledging governance may extend timelines to approximately 12 months (Module 1 Implementation Update, Cabinet Office, 8 July 2025).
- The July 2025 implementation update marked this recommendation as IN PROGRESS, with a UK-wide online repository for exercise information still to be created (Module 1 Implementation Update, Cabinet Office, 8 July 2025).
Response — verbatim from government
●Scottish Government — initial response
No formal response published by this government.
Scottish Government · 18 Jul 2024
●Welsh Government — follow-up
No formal response published by this government.
Welsh Government · 18 Jul 2024
●Northern Ireland Executive — follow-up
No formal response published by this government.
Northern Ireland Executive · 18 Jul 2024
●UK Government — follow-up
The government agrees that, given the UK-wide cross-cutting implications, the UK government should publish findings and lessons from all Tier 1 civil emergency exercises (except where there are justifiable reasons not to do so, such as national security concerns). Tier 1 exercises (as described in Recommendation 6) involve cross-government participation and relevant devolved government, regional and local responders.
The Academy Exercising Hub, which will form part of the UK Resilience Academy (UKRA) from its launch in April 2025, will ensure that government departments, devolved governments, local and regional tiers of government, and those in the voluntary and community sectors have access to the appropriate resources to strengthen exercising and lessons management. It will also fulfil a convening role, encouraging collaboration on exercising and lessons management across organisational silos.
As part of the vision and outputs for the UKRA the government published Lessons Management Best Practice Guidance on gov.uk in 2024. It has been designed to complement existing learning activities, be used in conjunction with established lessons’ platforms, and to support continual improvement at national and local levels.
The guidance sets best practice for the dissemination of a report summarising the findings, lessons and recommendations within three months of an exercise and advocates for the agreement of a strategic Implementation Action Plan within six months of the conclusion of an exercise. It should be recognised that for a Tier 1 exercise, the process of governance, debriefing, evaluating, disseminating and reviewing may take up to 12 months to make a report publicly available. The guidance also provides templates that can be used in the lesson management process. These include an Observation Capture Template, Cold Debrief Template and templates for a Lessons Management Register and Implementation Action Tracker which can be used for any exercise, regardless of scale.
To complement this guidance by providing context and highlighting examples of the lessons management process in practice, the UK Resilience Lessons Digest has been produced in collaboration with the Emergency Planning College. The publicly available Digest synthesises lessons learned from major exercises and emergencies, with each issue providing analysis of lessons arising from public facing reports generated after the events. It coordinates knowledge to promote continual improvement in UK resilience training, exercising, doctrine, standards and good practice.
A further established platform for capturing lessons is Joint Organisational Learning, hosted on ResilienceDirect. It is used to capture and share lessons identified from local and national multi-agency exercises and emergencies. The Joint Emergency Services Interoperability Programme team (responsible for encouraging interoperability across the emergency services and supported by a cross-government board) is actively working to encourage improved use of the platform to help minimise isolated lessons capture and limited sharing.
The government recognises that there is more to do to strengthen the systematic management of lessons from exercising. This will require a central, UK-wide online repository of information relating to civil emergency exercises, embedding the guidance on making effective recommendations in exercise reports, and a system that continues to promote a learning culture across teams, departments, organisations and multi-agency partners. The Cabinet Office is scoping and testing solutions to resolve this issue.
UK Government · 16 Jan 2025 Written response →
●UK Government — follow-up
[IN PROGRESS] UK Resilience Academy launched April 2025 with Exercising Hub. Cross-government Lessons Management framework under development. Commitment to publish Tier 1 exercise findings within approximately 12 months unless security classified.
UK Government · 8 Jul 2025 Written response →
Evidence trail — what's actually happened since
- 15 Oct 2025 Status: In Progress. The government agrees that, given the UK-wide cross-cutting implications, the UK government should publish findings and lessons from all Tier 1 civil emergency exercises (except where there are justifiable reasons not to do so, such as national security concerns). Tier 1 exercises (as described in Recommendation 6) involve cross-government participation and relevant devolved government, regional and local responders. The Academy Exercising Hub, which will form part of the UK Resilience Academy Source →
- 8 Jul 2025 · UK Government Implementation update (8 Jul 2025): [IN PROGRESS] UK Resilience Academy launched April 2025 with Exercising Hub. Cross-government Lessons Management framework under development. Commitment to publish Tier 1 exercise findings within approximately 12 months unless security classified. Source →
- 16 Jan 2025 The government agrees that, given the UK-wide cross-cutting implications, the UK government should publish findings and lessons from all Tier 1 civil emergency exercises (except where there are justifiable reasons not to do so, such as national security concerns). Tier 1 exercises (as described in Recommendation 6) involve cross-government participation and relevant devolved government, regional and local responders. The Academy Exercising Hub, which will form part of the UK Resilience Academy (UKRA) from its launch in April 2025, will ensure that government departments, devolved governments, local and regional tiers of government, and those in the voluntary and community sectors have access to the appropriate resources to strengthen exercising and lessons management. It will also fulfil a convening role, encouraging collaboration on exercising and lessons management across organisational silos. As part of the vision and outputs for the UKRA the government published Lessons Management Best Practice Guidance on gov.uk8 in 2024. It has been designed to complement existing learning activities, be used in conjunction with established lessons’ platforms, and to support continual improvement at national and local levels. The guidance sets best practice for the dissemination of a report summarising the findings, lessons and recommendations within three months of an exercise and advocates for the agreement of a strategic Implementation Action Plan within six months of the conclusion of an exercise. It should be recognised that for a Tier 1 8 Lessons Management Best Practice Guidance exercise, the process of governance, debriefing, evaluating, disseminating and reviewing may take up to 12 months to make a report publicly available. The guidance also provides templates that can be used in the lesson management process. These include an Observation Capture Template, Cold Debrief Template and templates for a Lessons Management Register and Implementation Action Tracker which can be used for any exercise, regardless of scale. To complement this guidance by providing context and highlighting examples of the lessons management process in practice, the UK Resilience Lessons Digest9 has been produced in collaboration with the Emergency Planning College. The publicly available Digest synthesises lessons learned from major exercises and emergencies, with each issue providing analysis of lessons arising from public facing reports generated after the events. It coordinates knowledge to promote continual improvement in UK resilience training, exercising, doctrine, standards and good practice. A further established platform for capturing lessons is Joint Organisational Learning10, hosted on ResilienceDirect. It is used to capture and share lessons identified from local and national multi-agency exercises and emergencies. The Joint Emergency Services Interoperability Programme11 team (responsible for encouraging interoperability across the emergency services and supported by a cross-government board) is actively working to encourage improved use of the platform to help minimise isolated lessons capture and limited sharing. The government recognises that there is more to do to strengthen the systematic management of lessons from exercising. This will require a central, UK-wide online repository of information relating to civil emergency exercises, embedding the guidance on making effective recommendations in exercise reports, and a system that continues to promote a learning culture across teams, departments, organisations and multi-agency partners. The Cabinet Office is scoping and testing solutions to resolve this issue. 9 UK Resilience Lessons Digest 10 https://www.jesip.org.uk/joint-organisational-learning/ 11 https://www.jesip.org.uk/ Source →
Each entry above links to a primary source — gov.uk written statement, consultation response document, or inspection report. The Index does not characterise government intent; it tracks what has been published.
How this page is built
Source and Response are verbatim from primary documents. The Evidence trail records published activity since — written statements, consultation outcomes, inspection findings, parliamentary references. The Index does not paraphrase or characterise intent; it tracks what has been published. Where the evidence is the absence of action (a missed deadline, a slipped timetable), that absence is documented from primary sources rather than inferred.
This recommendation's data is verified periodically against primary sources. The Index is monitored for staleness weekly.