sandra wood
Noted
The Trust states they do have facilities to provide CT scans during weekends and that scans are carried out on all patients that require them, based on a clinical decision; the Trust has taken the opportunity to re-iterate the processes in place to clinical staff regarding the availability of CT scanning 24/7 for urgent cases. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Hatch Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths following the inquest of Sandra Rhoda Marion Wood who died at Maidstone Hospital on 18 April 2015 am writing to respond to the concerns you raised your investigation into the death of Sandra Wood, and to explain the actions that Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust has taken in order to address those concerns
1) The NHS Trust does not have facilities for routine CT scans to be carried out during weekends. want to start by assuring you that we do have facilities to provide CT scans to our patients during the weekend and that we carry out CT scans on all patients that require them, based on a clinical decision; Over the weekend of 18-19 April 2015 (when Mrs Wood died) we carried out 139 CT scans on patients, based on a clinical decision for each patient. The challenge to provide like-for-like weekday and weekend service is not unique to this Trust, and like all NHS Trusts we strive to operate in a climate of limited resources and budget constraints set by central government: Similar to other Trusts, we provide 'routine' CT scanning through the week and during the daytime on Saturday and Sunday as those are the times when we can accommodate a greater throughput of scans and can provide the service for both routine (non-urgent) and urgent cases. Out of hours we provide an emergency service but it must be emphasised that there is no restriction on the number of emergency scans that can be performed.
2) If an urgent CT scans (sic) are necessary specific application procedure has to be in place. Chairman: Tony Jones Chief Executive: Glenn Douglas Trust headquarters: Maidstone Hospital, Hermitage Lane, Maidstone; Kent ME16 900 Telephone: 01622 729000 Fax 01622 226416 during put
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells [HS NHS Trust Respectfully would refer you to my response at (1) above, and restate that the decision whether or not to scan patient is based on nothing other than clinical judgement based on the patient's condition. The perceived barriers presented by our procedure for obtaining CT scans out of hours was concern raised by HM Coroner Patricia Harding in the Preventing Future Deaths report made on conclusion of the inquest touching the death of Christine McNamara Without rehearsing my response, am happy to assure you that there is sound reasoning behind our procedure. Patients fall under the care of consultants, but spend more time being actively treated by junior doctors To ensure that patients are appropriately escalated for treatment of worsening condition (in the full knowledge of the treating consultant) it is necessary to ensure that a consultant is aware when patient is to be sent for a CT scan at all times. On weekdays when consultants are more readily available on-site within the Trust these referrals are less noticeable than out of hours or on weekends, but the procedure is always in place attach for your information, a copy of our access policy for out of hours CT imaging: This policy is in effect daily for the period 1Opm 7am. During the period 8pm 1Opm the referrers contact the on-call radiologists, and between 7am 8pm there is access to the radiologist within the department and scans can be discussed face to face_ think it is helpful to highlight that CT scans are only one diagnostic tool of many at our disposal and in accordance with s.6 of The 'lonising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations 2000 (IR(MEJR) we are required to justify that there is sufficient net benefit (when weighed against the risks of radiation exposure) before scanning patient: Given the level of skill required and repercussions of unwarranted scans, the responsibility for that decision rests with our consultants
3) In this case despite the requirements for an urgent scan to be undertaken in potentially emergency situation the scan was to be delayed until after the weekend, which proved to be too late due to the fact that Mrs Woods died on Saturday 18th April
2015. As learning organisation the Trust is keen to ensure that we review and learn clinical cases to continually improve and acknowledge this is a distressing time for Mrs Wood's family: In the case of urgent scans_ there has been careful consideration of our systems and processes and we can provide assurance that where urgent scans are deemed t0 be required based on the clinical situation, that they are undertaken in a timely way: In this particular case the evidence provided by Drs Nguyen, Ibrahim and Smith indicated that the clinical presentation of Mrs Woods did not merit an urgent CT scan; Mrs Wood had no bowel distension, her bowel was soft and non-tender on examination and her X-ray results (which would highlight signs of obstruction) were unremarkable, as were her blood and urine test results However, the Trust has taken the opportunity to re-iterate the processes in place to clinical staff regarding the availability of CT scanning 24/7 for urgent cases. Chairman: Tony Jones Chief Executive: Glenn Douglas Trust Headquarters: Maidstone Hospital, Hermitage Lane, Maidstone, Kent ME16 900 Telephone; 01622 729000 Fax 01622 226416 time from
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells [HS] NHS Tnust The Trust strongly concurs that where there is a clinical indication CT scans should be undertaken regardless of or time: want to thank you for taking the time to bring your concerns to my attention, and trust that this response is to your satisfaction.
1) The NHS Trust does not have facilities for routine CT scans to be carried out during weekends. want to start by assuring you that we do have facilities to provide CT scans to our patients during the weekend and that we carry out CT scans on all patients that require them, based on a clinical decision; Over the weekend of 18-19 April 2015 (when Mrs Wood died) we carried out 139 CT scans on patients, based on a clinical decision for each patient. The challenge to provide like-for-like weekday and weekend service is not unique to this Trust, and like all NHS Trusts we strive to operate in a climate of limited resources and budget constraints set by central government: Similar to other Trusts, we provide 'routine' CT scanning through the week and during the daytime on Saturday and Sunday as those are the times when we can accommodate a greater throughput of scans and can provide the service for both routine (non-urgent) and urgent cases. Out of hours we provide an emergency service but it must be emphasised that there is no restriction on the number of emergency scans that can be performed.
2) If an urgent CT scans (sic) are necessary specific application procedure has to be in place. Chairman: Tony Jones Chief Executive: Glenn Douglas Trust headquarters: Maidstone Hospital, Hermitage Lane, Maidstone; Kent ME16 900 Telephone: 01622 729000 Fax 01622 226416 during put
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells [HS NHS Trust Respectfully would refer you to my response at (1) above, and restate that the decision whether or not to scan patient is based on nothing other than clinical judgement based on the patient's condition. The perceived barriers presented by our procedure for obtaining CT scans out of hours was concern raised by HM Coroner Patricia Harding in the Preventing Future Deaths report made on conclusion of the inquest touching the death of Christine McNamara Without rehearsing my response, am happy to assure you that there is sound reasoning behind our procedure. Patients fall under the care of consultants, but spend more time being actively treated by junior doctors To ensure that patients are appropriately escalated for treatment of worsening condition (in the full knowledge of the treating consultant) it is necessary to ensure that a consultant is aware when patient is to be sent for a CT scan at all times. On weekdays when consultants are more readily available on-site within the Trust these referrals are less noticeable than out of hours or on weekends, but the procedure is always in place attach for your information, a copy of our access policy for out of hours CT imaging: This policy is in effect daily for the period 1Opm 7am. During the period 8pm 1Opm the referrers contact the on-call radiologists, and between 7am 8pm there is access to the radiologist within the department and scans can be discussed face to face_ think it is helpful to highlight that CT scans are only one diagnostic tool of many at our disposal and in accordance with s.6 of The 'lonising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations 2000 (IR(MEJR) we are required to justify that there is sufficient net benefit (when weighed against the risks of radiation exposure) before scanning patient: Given the level of skill required and repercussions of unwarranted scans, the responsibility for that decision rests with our consultants
3) In this case despite the requirements for an urgent scan to be undertaken in potentially emergency situation the scan was to be delayed until after the weekend, which proved to be too late due to the fact that Mrs Woods died on Saturday 18th April
2015. As learning organisation the Trust is keen to ensure that we review and learn clinical cases to continually improve and acknowledge this is a distressing time for Mrs Wood's family: In the case of urgent scans_ there has been careful consideration of our systems and processes and we can provide assurance that where urgent scans are deemed t0 be required based on the clinical situation, that they are undertaken in a timely way: In this particular case the evidence provided by Drs Nguyen, Ibrahim and Smith indicated that the clinical presentation of Mrs Woods did not merit an urgent CT scan; Mrs Wood had no bowel distension, her bowel was soft and non-tender on examination and her X-ray results (which would highlight signs of obstruction) were unremarkable, as were her blood and urine test results However, the Trust has taken the opportunity to re-iterate the processes in place to clinical staff regarding the availability of CT scanning 24/7 for urgent cases. Chairman: Tony Jones Chief Executive: Glenn Douglas Trust Headquarters: Maidstone Hospital, Hermitage Lane, Maidstone, Kent ME16 900 Telephone; 01622 729000 Fax 01622 226416 time from
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells [HS] NHS Tnust The Trust strongly concurs that where there is a clinical indication CT scans should be undertaken regardless of or time: want to thank you for taking the time to bring your concerns to my attention, and trust that this response is to your satisfaction.