Source · Prevention of Future Deaths

Gwendoline Clarke

Ref: 2016-0218 Date: 8 Jun 2016 Coroner: Katy Skerrett Area: Gloucestershire Responses identified: 1 / 2 View PDF

Staff failed to report a resident's injury and delayed escalating allegations of abuse for approximately 12 hours.

Date 8 Jun 2016
56-day deadline 3 Aug 2016 est.
Responses identified 1 of 2
Care Home Health related deaths

Coroner's concerns

AI summary
Staff failed to report a resident's injury and delayed escalating allegations of abuse for approximately 12 hours.
View full coroner's concerns
Gloucestershire Coroner'$ Court; Corinium Avenue Barnwood, Gloucester, GLA 3DJ Tel 01452 305661 Fax 01452 412618 Katy Katy Betty Trees Tuffley, During The

(1) No member of staff reported the injury that Betty sustained, and (2) No member of staff escalated Betty's allegations that a member of staff had hurt her until approximately 12 hours after she first made the allegation:

Responses

1 respondent
Social Care
PDF
Action Planned

The organisation plans to re-enforce the safeguarding policy, update job descriptions, include admission process under general screening, audit care plan, re-enforce home's protocols for unwitnessed accidents, plan training and supervision refresher first aid, review the home's management and on-call process. (AI summary)

View full response
PRIVATE & CONFIDENTIAL Pine Tree Court Response to Coroner's Report Introduction respond to the HM Coroner'$ Report dated 8.6.16 in relation to the death of Gwendoline Betty Clark who refers to the cause of death as respiratory failure, sepsis, pancreatitis, diabetes and bilateral femoral fractures The Coroner refers tq concerns in point 4 in order to prevent possible future deaths, the matters are a5 follows: Reporting of the injury that was sustained A 12 hour delay in escalation and safeguarding matters in relation to the allegations that a member of staff had hurt her. Background and Facts The lady concerned had a number of long term conditions including mental health issues resulting in paranoia and there was a history of regular accusations made against staff as well as others. She also took medication that would of course affect the bone structure: Betty moved aroundthe home freely, she had suffered previous unwitnessed falls due to her level of independence_ There is no reference that any staff were indeed aware of any falls or occurrences that could have resulted in such injury, this was confirmed by the investigation nor was there any person on duty that Betty had described who had allegedly caused the harm_ The circumstances remain that there was a delay in requesting aid, a delay in the attendance of the emergency services and delays in reporting the safeguarding matter at the weekend/bank holiday period when the office was closed. This was clearly outside of these times (office hours Monday Friday 8-5.30pm) hence the stated of 12 hours_ Actions An analysis of the report and taking on board the concerns raised through the process, the following actions are necessary: Action By Who/When Evaluation Re-enforce the safeguarding policy, share with all July 2016 Audit PLJ Within hore staff and use this as supervision; include out of August hours reporting process and the manager absence, check staff awareness and knowledge of this process_ This also includes an update of the Job Description (RN) Include the admission process under general PU Document screening fok our clients, an assessment to determine June 2016 Key being police delay Copv

those more at risk of fractures due to medical problems and lack of sunlight Audit of Care Include relevant signs/symptoms within the monthly Plan health chedk check Quality File each month re use of accident log Re-enforce the home' $ protocols for unwitnessed Training Record accidents ahd remind staff regarding examination, Julv 2016 Analysis clinical judgement and pain management see enc pain chart Plan training and supervision refresher first aid Certification particularlyto focus on fracture detection
5.7.16 Review thelhome's management and on-call process Complete New registered both home Manager and regional support manager manager have now changed pending Intensify thE abuse audit and surveys to complete Ito check re each month for a 12 month period quality file compliance vii Utilise the company escalation tool in order to Complete and to check highlight the practise of the ambulance service Ongoing during care plan particularlylin relation to handling techniques check audit Sept 16 use of SBAR viii Conduct a reflective piece, include qualified staff and Complete 0 hold on use for NMC revalidation June 2016 file and distribute to nurses (own copy) Refer the issue for external investigation (Bob Taylor) July 2016 Personnel file and review possible breeches in conduct as well as NMC code Explore thelout of hours safeguarding service within June 2016 Poster available Gloucester_and circulate details with the home

Report sections

Investigation and inquest
On the 2"d January 2015 commenced an investigation into the death of Gwendoline Clarke. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on the 7th June 2016. The conclusion of the inquest was an open conclusion and a narrative conclusion. The medical cause of death was 1A respiratory failure, sepsis, and pancreatitis in woman with diabetes , 1B bilateral femoral fractures
Circumstances of the death
Mrs Clarke "Betty" was an 89 year old lady who had a significant medical history including cerebral meningioma which was removed in 2011, diabetes, cerebrovascular disease, longstanding anxiety and depression, renal failure and chronic obstructive airways disease She was long term resident at Pine Court Care home, Gloucester;, having moved there in 2011. She had two admissions to hospital in August and October 2014 with chest related problems_ She was able to mobilise using a walking aid and or with assistance from carers However her mobility was gradually deteriorating: On the 24h December she was on antibiotics for a chest infection. During the day on the 27h December 2014 she appeared her usual self the morning on Sunday 28"h December Betty was complaining that she had leg pain and that a member of staff had hurt her. She made several members of staff aware of that fact. No medical review from doctor was sought: Police were not informed, Emergency services were requested at approximately 21.45 hours. Paramedics arrived at 1.15am on the 29t December;, and transferred Betty to hospital. She was admitted to hospital in the early hours of the morning on the 29lh December 2014 having sustained injuries to her legs and chest; including multiple fractures. These injuries were caused by significant incident probably occurring during the morning of the 28" December 2014. mechanical cause of these injuries whether due to a falll how she was handled by a carer remains unclear: It is more probable than not that a member of staff was aware that Betty had sustained significant injury, and did not report that fact. Police were informed by hospital staff in the Accident and Emergency Department After admission to hospital she subsequently deteriorated with clinical evidence of respiratory failure and sepsis. Her clinical deterioration was related to her underlying injuries Her medical history made her more vulnerable to such a decline. She died at 06.43 hours on the 31* December 2014-
Action should be taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you have the power to take such action.

Similar PFD reports

Shared signals

Related inquiry recommendations

Similar themes

Report details

Reference
2016-0218
Date of report
8 June 2016
Coroner
Katy Skerrett
Coroner area
Gloucestershire

Responses identified

Responses identified 1 of 2
1 response not yet linked

Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 3 Aug 2016 (estimated).

Sent to

ADL PLC
Care Quality Commission

Source links