Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Kenneth Bardsley
Ref: 2018-0407
Date: 27 Dec 2018
Coroner: Alison Mutch
Area: Manchester (South)
Responses identified: 0 / 5
View PDF
The coroner raises concerns regarding the lack of minimum qualification standards for lift engineers, the absence of an escalation process for regulatory lift examination results, a lack of clarity on engineers following up on requirements, CQC's failure to identify unaddressed faults, and a lack of systems to ensure lift examination details are read and acted upon.
Date
27 Dec 2018
56-day deadline
21 Feb 2019 est.
Responses identified
0 of 5
Coroner's concerns
The coroner raises concerns regarding the lack of minimum qualification standards for lift engineers, the absence of an escalation process for regulatory lift examination results, a lack of clarity on engineers following up on requirements, CQC's failure to identify unaddressed faults, and a lack of systems to ensure lift examination details are read and acted upon.
View full coroner's concerns
1. The inquest heard that there are no formal requirements for a minimum standard of qualification for people to be lift engineers. In effect; anyone can advertise themselves as a lift engineerlmaintenance company;
2. The evidence given to the inquest was that there was a gap in the system which meant that regulatory lift examinations could take place but not be read or acted upon, with no escalation process;
3. During the inquest evidence was given that within the specific lift company in this case and more widely, there was a lack of clarity as to how engineers should be made aware and follow up requirements made by engineers carrying out the regulatory lift examinations;
4. In inspections of the home, the CQC did not pick Up that there were faults identified in the regulatory examination that had not been acted upon;
5. That Serendipity Care Home did not have a system in place to ensure details from the lift examinations were read; considered and passed on to the lift servicing company;
6. That the lift company Lancs and Cumbria engineers carrying out servinglrepairs were not expected to ask to see the regulatory examination reports; That the lift company Lancs and Cumbria Lifts had abandoned their old paper checklists and introduced an electronic appointment system: However that system did not include an electronic checklist. had now been introduced. It was unclear if other companies have checklists and if so how consistent are The inquest heard that there was no statutory minimum expectation about the requirements of a lift service
2. The evidence given to the inquest was that there was a gap in the system which meant that regulatory lift examinations could take place but not be read or acted upon, with no escalation process;
3. During the inquest evidence was given that within the specific lift company in this case and more widely, there was a lack of clarity as to how engineers should be made aware and follow up requirements made by engineers carrying out the regulatory lift examinations;
4. In inspections of the home, the CQC did not pick Up that there were faults identified in the regulatory examination that had not been acted upon;
5. That Serendipity Care Home did not have a system in place to ensure details from the lift examinations were read; considered and passed on to the lift servicing company;
6. That the lift company Lancs and Cumbria engineers carrying out servinglrepairs were not expected to ask to see the regulatory examination reports; That the lift company Lancs and Cumbria Lifts had abandoned their old paper checklists and introduced an electronic appointment system: However that system did not include an electronic checklist. had now been introduced. It was unclear if other companies have checklists and if so how consistent are The inquest heard that there was no statutory minimum expectation about the requirements of a lift service
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 1st February 2017 commenced an investigation into the death of Kenneth Roy Bardsley: The jury inquest concluded on the 26th November 2018 and the conclusion of the jury was one of Accidental death contributed to by failure of interior door mechanism; The medical cause of death was 1a) Multiple injuries; 2) Osteoporosis; Ischaemic heart disease; Valvular heart disease Mr Kenneth Bardsley died on the 30th January 2017 , at Salford Royal Hospital due to multiple injuries, received as a passenger in a lift, which malfunctioned at Serendipity Care Home
Action should be taken
In my opinion, action should be taken to prevent future deaths and | believe you have the power t0 take such action.
Copies sent to
13) Bureau Veritas Ltd
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Southport Inquiry
Out-of-school settings guidance update
Fuller Inquiry
Care homes in scope for new regulatory regime
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Require external wall information for fire services
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Train fire personnel on external wall fire risks
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
LFB to review PN633 Appendix 1
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Require evacuation plans for high-rise buildings
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Urgent fire door inspections required
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Require quarterly fire door checks
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Require compliant flat entrance doors where unsafe cladding exists
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Train LFB officers on high-rise inspections
Report details
- Reference
- 2018-0407
- Date of report
- 27 December 2018
- Coroner
- Alison Mutch
- Coroner area
- Manchester (South)
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 5
5 responses not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 21 Feb 2019 (estimated).
Sent to
- Care Quality Commission
- Department for Work and Pensions
- Health and Safety Executive
- Lancs & Cumbria Lifts UK Ltd
- Serendipity Care Home