Source · Prevention of Future Deaths

Andrew Gibbins

Ref: 2020-0290 Date: 17 Dec 2020 Coroner: Jacqueline Devonish Area: Suffolk Responses identified: 2 / 1 View PDF

A security guard's concern about a patient expressing suicidal feelings was not reported to clinical staff at the hospital, leading to a missed opportunity for assessment.

Date 17 Dec 2020
56-day deadline 18 Feb 2021
Responses identified 2 of 1
Hospital Death (Clinical Procedures and medical management) related deaths Mental Health related deaths Suicide (from 2015)

Coroner's concerns

AI summary
A security guard's concern about a patient expressing suicidal feelings was not reported to clinical staff at the hospital, leading to a missed opportunity for assessment.
View full coroner's concerns
(1) The Hospital Security Guard guided Andrew Gibbins back to AAU looking lost and confused (following a cigarette break) when in a general way saying that he was feeling suicidal and that that had been the reason why he was under the care of Wedgewood. There were no immediate concerns for him, but the Security Guard had been concerned enough to ask for the Wedgewood staff member escort when he returned to AAU. Andrew’s presentation had not been reported to any clinician at either AAU or Wedgwood.

Responses

2 respondents
West Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust NHS / Health Body
17 Feb 2021 PDF
Action Taken

The Trusts have commenced monthly meetings between the head of mental health and the lead nurse, and reviewed the handover process, incorporating SBAR documentation into the WSFT risk assessment. The acute hospital missing person’s policy has been reviewed and deemed fit for purpose in January 2021. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Coroner

Re: Andrew Gibbins Deceased – Regulation 28 (Prevention of Future Deaths)

Thank you for your letter regarding the investigation into the death of Mr Andrew Gibbins.

I have asked our Head of Patient Safety, Head of Deteriorating Patient and Head of Mental Health to address the matters of concern that you have over the actions in the joint action plan with the Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust - the response is as follows;

Recommendation Two - Cohesive working between both Trusts with particular regards to joint working and inter Trust protocols;

The Trusts have commenced monthly meetings between the head of mental health and the lead nurse for NSFT’s West Suffolk Care Group to ensure cohesive working/trouble shooting and good communication. These meetings are minuted for action planning, service improvement and assurance purposes.

The handover process has been reviewed and when a patient is transferred from NSFT to WSFT for a physical health intervention the SBAR documentation will be handed over to WSFT staff. This information will be incorporated into the WSFT risk assessment. This will be incorporated into the acute hospital mental health policy by 31 May 2021.

Recommendation Three – Acute hospital to review the missing person’s policy;

The acute hospital missing person’s policy has been reviewed in January 2021 and deemed fit for purpose - attached.

Jacqueline Devonish H M Coroner Coroners Service Beacon House White House Road Ipswich Suffolk IP1 5PB

Chief Executive’s Office West Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust Hardwick Lane Bury St Edmunds Suffolk IP33 2QZ

Recommendation Four – Acute hospital and ambulance Trusts to review communication processes.

We have reviewed our communication process with the Ambulance Trust who have informed us that they did pass the information to us (as would be normal process for them), but on this occasion it appears there was some miscommunication. It has been reinforced with the staff involved the importance of ensuring all information has been received and documented correctly.

I hope that the above information and evidence provides you with a level of assurance in making your final decision and thank you for your consideration in this sad inquest.
Hellesdon Hospital NHS / Health Body
18 Mar 2021 PDF
Action Taken

Hellesdon Hospital reports that they have established regular interface meetings with the West Suffolk Hospital to improve communication and have formalized these meetings with agreed actions and minutes for governance purposes. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Ms Devonish, The inquest of Andrew Gibbins Following the inquest of Mr Andrew Gibbins on 1st December 2020 you issued a Prevention of Future Deaths Regulation 28 Notice to NSFT and the West Suffolk Hospital. We were surprised to receive this due to confirmation at the inquest that no such notice would be issued to any of the parties involved however; we understand that on reflection you felt communication needed to be improved between the two hospitals. To this end would like to reassure you that we have taken your concern seriously and have in place regular interface meeting with the West Suffolk Hospital to date we have held five such meetings. These previously were informal however we have moved these to a formal footing with agreed actions and minutes for governance purposes_ This meeting is attended by senior staff who are authorised to make decisions: and implement improvements, actions are tracked, and communication pathways have been strengthen as a result hope this provides you with the information you need to assure you that communication has improved between the two providers_

Report sections

Investigation and inquest
On 6 March 2020 I commenced an investigation into the death of Andrew Gibbins, 54. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 1 December 2020. The conclusion of the inquest was that he died from multiple skull and rib fracture with pneumohaemothorax due to a road traffic collision and that he had taken his own life.
Circumstances of the death
On 15.01.2020 Mr Gibbins who had a long history of mental health informal admissions ran into the path of a lorry on the A14 Westbound. Eye witnesses confirmed that his actions were deliberate. His injuries were incompatible with life. Recognition of Life Extinct (ROLE) at 20:50 hours. Mr Gibbins had been unescorted awaiting test results on Acute Assessment Unit (AAU). He had expressed to a security guard that he was feeling suicidal and that was why he was under Wedgewood unit. He appeared withdrawn but this information did not reach Wedgewood or the Staff Nurse.

Similar PFD reports

Shared signals

Related inquiry recommendations

Similar themes

Report details

Reference
2020-0290
Date of report
17 December 2020
Coroner
Jacqueline Devonish
Coroner area
Suffolk

Responses identified

Responses identified 2 of 1
All listed responses identified

Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 18 Feb 2021.

Sent to

West Suffolk Hospital and The Wedgewood Unit, Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust

Source links