Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Mohammed Zeb
Ref: 2021-0096
Date: 30 Mar 2021
Coroner: John Broadbridge
Area: North Yorkshire, Western District
Responses identified: 0 / 1
View PDF
A critical lack of accessible water rescue aids, including flotation devices or throw lines, at the incident scene hindered efforts to save a non-swimmer.
Date
30 Mar 2021
56-day deadline
3 Jun 2021
Responses identified
0 of 1
Coroner's concerns
A critical lack of accessible water rescue aids, including flotation devices or throw lines, at the incident scene hindered efforts to save a non-swimmer.
View full coroner's concerns
(1) Recognising the Deceased’s inability to swim and that he was soon unresponsive, there were nevertheless no aids eg flotation aid, throw line or water rescue reach pole to help the rescuers, or the deceased himself if he had been responsive, accessible at the scene of the incident. OFFICIAL - SENSITIVE
(2) Police Officers and paramedics courageously had to swim and put themselves at risk to try and reach the casualty and support the deceased’s body while CPR was attempted in less than helpful physical positions and conditions for recovery of an inert casualty. Recognising that the Falls are a popular open, natural attraction, valued for its natural features, nevertheless the steep banks and rocks permit no ready access to places of safety and support for casualties. It was not until a team from Upper Wharfedale Fell Rescue attended that he was able to be moved to a more suitable location.
- (3) No one present appeared to have been aware of any safety warnings either at the location or by other media about risks to life from cold water, current] speed of water flow, underwater obstructions and obstacles, all ‘unseen’ hazards. Further that such risks do not disappear - instead vary, remaining hazardous - in summer months even after drop in water levels.
(2) Police Officers and paramedics courageously had to swim and put themselves at risk to try and reach the casualty and support the deceased’s body while CPR was attempted in less than helpful physical positions and conditions for recovery of an inert casualty. Recognising that the Falls are a popular open, natural attraction, valued for its natural features, nevertheless the steep banks and rocks permit no ready access to places of safety and support for casualties. It was not until a team from Upper Wharfedale Fell Rescue attended that he was able to be moved to a more suitable location.
- (3) No one present appeared to have been aware of any safety warnings either at the location or by other media about risks to life from cold water, current] speed of water flow, underwater obstructions and obstacles, all ‘unseen’ hazards. Further that such risks do not disappear - instead vary, remaining hazardous - in summer months even after drop in water levels.
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 3 August 2020 an investigation commenced into the death of MOHAMMED BILAL ZES, aged 18 years. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 25 March 2021. The Conclusion of the inquest was that the deceased died because of drowning, to which COVID 19 and asthma were said to be contributory, and that his death was accidental.
Circumstances of the death
On 31 July 2020 the deceased was at Linton Falls on the River Wharfe near Linton with family and friends. Although he could not swim, he jumped into the River and got into difficulties. Persons present tried to help but he became unresponsive. He was recovered eventually to a large rock where resuscitation compressions were attempted, then to the riverbank. He was recognised as deceased there at 21.18 hours that same evening from drowning.
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
COVID-19 Inquiry
Fit-Testing Preparedness
Cranston Inquiry
Network flexing risk mitigation
Cranston Inquiry
Equipment and techniques development
Cranston Inquiry
Joint training exercises plan
Southport Inquiry
Police-ambulance terminology interoperability
Southport Inquiry
Out-of-school settings guidance update
Southport Inquiry
Police use of unarmed officers in immediate threat
Southport Inquiry
Second Force Incident Manager support
Southport Inquiry
Ambulance staff training exercise funding
Southport Inquiry
NWAS Major Incident declaration procedures
Report details
- Reference
- 2021-0096
- Date of report
- 30 March 2021
- Coroner
- John Broadbridge
- Coroner area
- North Yorkshire, Western District
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 1
1 response not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 3 Jun 2021.
Sent to
- Craven District Council, Yorkshire Dales National Park and Yorkshire Water