Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Clinton Fear
Current guidelines inconsistently notify patients of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection risk only for post-January 2013 surgeries, despite earlier evidence, potentially delaying diagnosis and harming patients from prior procedures.
Date
29 Jun 2023
56-day deadline
31 Aug 2023
Responses identified
0 of 1
Coroner's concerns
Current guidelines inconsistently notify patients of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection risk only for post-January 2013 surgeries, despite earlier evidence, potentially delaying diagnosis and harming patients from prior procedures.
View full coroner's concerns
1. There is an inconsistency between –
Previous Public Health England and current NHS guidance only to notify patients undergoing surgery from January 2013 of the risk of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection
And
Evidence of patients contracting Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from surgery substantially earlier than January 2013 (at least as far back as 2008);
2. There appears to be no current basis for maintaining a start date of surgery in January 2013 for patient risk notification when there is evidence of infection substantially earlier than this date;
3. Patients who have contracted Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from surgery before January 2013 may be suffering a delay in diagnosis and consequent harm as a result of a lack of notification due to the existing guidelines.
Previous Public Health England and current NHS guidance only to notify patients undergoing surgery from January 2013 of the risk of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection
And
Evidence of patients contracting Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from surgery substantially earlier than January 2013 (at least as far back as 2008);
2. There appears to be no current basis for maintaining a start date of surgery in January 2013 for patient risk notification when there is evidence of infection substantially earlier than this date;
3. Patients who have contracted Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from surgery before January 2013 may be suffering a delay in diagnosis and consequent harm as a result of a lack of notification due to the existing guidelines.
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 26th July 2022 an investigation into the death of Mr. Clinton Peter Fear was commenced. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest 29th June 2023. The conclusion of the inquest was -
Mr Fear died from a Mycobacterium Chimaera infection acquired from a Liva Nova heater cooler unit during open heart surgery.
The cause of death was –
1a) Hospital acquired pneumonia; b) Disseminated Mycobacterium Chimaera infection following a composite aortic root replacement (November 2012).
Mr Fear died from a Mycobacterium Chimaera infection acquired from a Liva Nova heater cooler unit during open heart surgery.
The cause of death was –
1a) Hospital acquired pneumonia; b) Disseminated Mycobacterium Chimaera infection following a composite aortic root replacement (November 2012).
Circumstances of the death
Mr Fear underwent cardiac valve replacement surgery in November 2012 and during surgery he contracted Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from a Liva Nova heater cooler unit (part of the heart bypass machine). He developed symptoms of Mycobacterium Chimaera in the form of night sweats in 2017/2018, was diagnosed and started on treatment in October 2019, suffered a protracted disabling illness for 3 years and died from the infection in July 2022.
He was not notified of the risk of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from the operation when this risk became known in 2015 because his operation was before January 2013 – the date from which patients were then considered to be at risk and adopted in guidance from Public Health England. Mr Fear contracted his Mycobacterium Chimaera infection at surgery before January 2013 and other cases have been reported from surgery dating back to at least 2008.
He was not notified of the risk of Mycobacterium Chimaera infection from the operation when this risk became known in 2015 because his operation was before January 2013 – the date from which patients were then considered to be at risk and adopted in guidance from Public Health England. Mr Fear contracted his Mycobacterium Chimaera infection at surgery before January 2013 and other cases have been reported from surgery dating back to at least 2008.
Copies sent to
University Hospital Bristol and Weston NHS Trust. North Bristol NHS Trust
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Infected Blood Inquiry
Pre-1996 Transfusion Testing
Infected Blood Inquiry
Eligibility Conditions for Infected Persons
Penrose Inquiry
HCV Testing for Pre-1991 Transfusion Recipients
Vale of Leven Inquiry
CDI senior assessment and treatment
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Laboratory specimen processing
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Effective CDI patient isolation
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Isolation for infectious diarrhoea
Report details
- Reference
- 2023-0286
- Date of report
- 29 June 2023
- Coroner
- Simon Fox
- Coroner area
- Avon
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 1
1 response not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 31 Aug 2023.
Sent to
- UK Health Security Agency