Select committee: Business, Innovation, Science and Trade Committee

Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing

Closed Opened 17 Jan 2023 Closed 24 May 2024 13 recommendations 10 conclusions
Inquiry scope (the committee's words)
The Committee has launched this inquiry into the supply of batteries for electric vehicle manufacture in the UK, and the viability of battery manufacturing for electric vehicles in the UK. The industry has recently suffered a series of setbacks, including the Government-championed battery start-up Britishvolt which entered administration in January 2022. The Committee is interested in the UK's potential to scale-up battery manufacturing to meet growing demand for electric vehicles domestically and globally, including what lessons the UK can learn from other countries.

Where it stands

The inquiry is closed, opened 17 January 2023.

The committee has published 1 report, most recently First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing on 21 November 2023.

The government's response

Published 14 February 2024. The deadline was 21 January 2024.

Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.

The government's response sets out existing and announced support for batteries, while declining fixed supply-chain targets and a subsidy race and leaving offtake agreements to commercial parties.

  • On the proposed 90% domestic supply target, the government says the Strategy has not set fixed targets, and that onshoring all aspects of critical mineral supply chains is not "possible (or even desirable)".
  • On international competitiveness, it says the UK "won't be drawn into a distortive subsidy battle" and points to £2 billion of capital and R&D funding for zero emission vehicles, batteries and supply chains to 2030.
  • On offtake agreements, it says these "remain a matter for the commercial parties involved to negotiate". On Tata's subsidy, it will publish details on the UK Subsidy Database "in due course".
  • On battery passports, the response notes the Strategy's points on data and regulation, and commits to Defra consultations in 2024 and a UK Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism by 2027, with design details "subject to consultation in 2024".

Read the government's response ↗ Report an error

Recommendations and conclusions 23 shown

1: Specify domestic supply targets for UK battery demand by 2030 and 2040, including scaling-up plan

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
In the forthcoming UK Battery Strategy, the Government should specify the extent to which future demand for batteries in the UK should be supplied by domestic sources in 2030 and 2040, along with a 10-year plan for scaling-up this capacity and an estimate of the public money required to do so. To match our competitors, the UK Government should consider targeting at least 90% of the UK’s annual demand for batteries to be met from domestic supplies by 2030.

Link to this item · Read this item

2: Outline battery manufacturing capacity for niche automotive and support non-automotive suppliers

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The UK needs gigafactories that can cater for the diverse array of vehicles, including luxury cars, public transport and commercial vehicles, manufactured in this country. Retaining niche segments of the automotive market in the UK is strategically important, because the highly specialised nature of these vehicles provides an opportunity to encourage innovative battery manufacturers into the UK. The UK also has an opportunity to take the lead in supplying forms of transport (rail, maritime, aviation and micro-mobility) and sectors of the economy (e.g. energy storage and military applications), which are expected to see demand for batteries rise, especially from 2030 onwards. To capitalise on these opportunities, the Government should: • outline, in the Advanced Manufacturing Plan, what UK battery manufacturing capacity will be needed to cater for the diverse needs of niche segments of the automotive industry, and by when, together with the measures required to secure this. • support battery manufacturers looking to supply batteries to non-automotive sectors by stimulating demand for batteries in these industries and ensuring government support is available to manufacturers targeting these market segments.

Link to this item · Read this item

3: Set out plan to attract established and new battery gigafactory manufacturers to UK

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
Encouraging a competitive mix of battery manufacturers to locate in the UK will help to build the supply chain while capturing intellectual property from new technologies. The Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy must set out how the Government plans to attract established battery manufacturers as well as new entrants to the battery market to build gigafactories in the UK. Those plans could include a twin-track process for access to financial support to reflect the differences between firms at different stages of development.

Link to this item · Read this item

4: Facilitate offtake agreements between OEMs and battery manufacturers for gigafactory funding

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
Having secure orders from an anchor customer is critical if battery manufacturers are going to raise sufficient funds to build a gigafactory. Offtake agreements between OEMs and battery manufacturers help signal to investors that there is demand for their product. The Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy should set out ways in which the Government could help to facilitate offtake agreements between OEMs and battery manufacturers.

Link to this item · Read this item

5: Designate gigafactory sites as strategically important and grant special economic status

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
There are limited number of potential gigafactory sites—but we have enough sites in the UK to meet the nation’s needs, including sites in the UK’s key automotive clusters. These sites are strategic national assets and should be treated as such. The Government must designate gigafactory sites as strategically important sites and 50 Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing work with local partners to put together a targeted package of support, with a view to attracting investors and ensuring gigafactories can be built at pace. These sites should be given priority for improvements to energy and transport infrastructure. The Government should work with local partners to grant those areas special economic status.

Link to this item · Read this item

6: Establish a single project office, led by DBT, to coordinate gigafactory support.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
Building a gigafactory will require support from central Government Departments, local authorities and private companies such as National Grid. The transaction cost of co-ordinating between these bodies should not fall on investors. A single project office integrating the full panoply of public support drawn from the various bodies involved is required, and the Department for Business and Trade should take on that lead role, as ‘gold command’.

Link to this item · Read this item

7: Publish the scale and scope of government support for the Jaguar Land Rover gigafactory.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
Tata Group’s plans to build a gigafactory in the UK provide a much-needed boost to the UK’s gigafactory pipeline, especially after Britishvolt’s administration earlier this year. We congratulate the Department on its efforts to secure this investment, following close competition from other markets. However, we reiterate our preference that the scale and scope of support offered to Jaguar Land Rover should be in the public domain.

Link to this item · Read this item

8: Gigafactory expansion capacity for other manufacturers lacks clarity.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
We are pleased that this new gigafactory will supply batteries to Jaguar Land Rover’s suite of electric vehicles built in the UK. However, we would welcome more clarity on the extent to which this facility can be expanded to cater for other manufacturers, within and outside the automotive industry. Battery supply chain

Link to this item · Read this item

9: Specify strategically critical industrial capabilities to onshore within the UK battery supply chain.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
It is not feasible or desirable to onshore the end-to-end battery supply chain. The UK cannot have a self-sufficient supply of lithium-ion batteries and will continue to rely to some degree on imports of raw minerals, materials and components. However, building the UK’s industrial capabilities across the battery supply chain, and especially in midstream processes such as the refining of raw minerals and the manufacture of cathodes and anodes, will confer strategic advantages. The Government should specify the industrial capabilities within the UK battery supply chain that are strategically critical to onshore along with new interventions that will encourage relevant businesses to locate in the UK. Such specifications could be set out either in the forthcoming UK Battery Strategy or in response to this Report.

Link to this item · Read this item

10: UK dependence on China-concentrated global battery supply chains poses significant strategic risks.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
Global battery supply chains, and especially the upstream supply of critical minerals, have environmental, social and governance challenges. Those supply chains are concentrated in China. The UK’s dependence on those supply chains poses risks to the UK and to the Government’s strategic objectives, especially if China were to restrict exports of the materials and components that the UK needs. It is critical that the UK Government continues to collaborate internationally not only to diversify the battery supply chain, but to ensure that batteries are produced to high environmental and social standards.

Link to this item · Read this item

11: Detail how the UK Battery Strategy will promote robust ESG standards across the battery industry.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The UK Battery Strategy should set out how the Government plans to promote robust environmental, social and governance standards across the battery industry domestically and globally to promote transparency and a green and clean battery supply.

Link to this item · Read this item

12: Require all batteries on the UK market to include a comprehensive battery passport.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
A battery supply chain in the UK would enable businesses based in this country to manufacture batteries sustainably and ethically. This offers the UK a competitive advantage over other markets, especially as consumers demand higher environmental, social and governance standards. The UK’s access to low-carbon sources of electricity means that batteries produced in the UK will be produced more sustainably than those in China and many European countries. The Government should empower UK consumers by requiring batteries available on the UK market to come with a battery passport containing information about how sustainably and ethically those batteries were produced.

Link to this item · Read this item

13: Implement an internationally competitive package of long-term support for gigafactories and battery supply chain.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
Global competition for the electric vehicle supply chain has intensified following the passing of the Inflation Reduction Act in the United States. The Inflation Reduction Act has seen investment flow into the electric vehicle supply chain, especially gigafactories, in the United States at the expense of Europe. The UK Government must urgently respond to this intensified global competition with an internationally competitive package of long-term support to attract private investment into gigafactories and the wider battery supply chain within the UK.

Link to this item · Read this item

14: Provide a long-term stable business environment to de-risk investments in the UK battery supply chain.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
The UK is competing against other large markets that are offering large subsidies to boost domestic production of electric vehicles and batteries and onshore businesses in the supply chain. The UK Government does not necessarily need to match the scale of subsidies on offer in these markets if the UK’s overall package is internationally competitive. However, the UK Government must provide a long-term stable business environment, with a clear framework of support that de-risks investments in the UK’s battery supply chain.

Link to this item · Read this item

15: Adopt an integrated approach to develop industrial capabilities across the battery value chain.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The absence of a clear and visible industrial strategy for the UK’s automotive sector had deterred investment in the UK. The forthcoming publication of the Government’s Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy should help to address that lack of investment. The Government should adopt an integrated approach, with measures to develop industrial capabilities across the battery value chain and to collaborate internationally with friends and partners with rich sources of battery minerals. The Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy must set out how the Government plans to capitalise on the UK’s sources of competitive advantage and also to address structural barriers that are deterring investment in the UK’s battery supply chain.

Link to this item · Read this item

16: Conduct and publish a benchmarking review of UK battery industry financial support against competitor countries.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The Automotive Transformation Fund has helped to unlock private investment into the UK, including in gigafactories and businesses further up the supply chain. However, now global competition has intensified, the UK Government needs to ensure that financial support on offer in the UK is internationally competitive. The Government should conduct a benchmarking review to determine how the financial 52 Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing support on offer compares with that available in competitor countries. It should publish this review and use the findings to inform a new offer of support for the UK’s battery industry in its forthcoming UK Battery Strategy.

Link to this item · Read this item

17: Set out interventions to provide investors with long-term certainty on competitive UK energy prices.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
High energy prices in the UK are deterring investment in the battery supply chain. The Government has taken steps to support energy-intensive industries. However, investors still need more certainty that UK energy prices will remain internationally competitive. The Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy should set out further interventions that will provide investors with more long-term certainty that the UK’s energy prices will be competitive with other markets.

Link to this item · Read this item

18: Set out forecast labour market, training costs, and plans to reskill automotive sector professionals.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The UK faces skills shortages across the battery supply chain. The Advanced Manufacturing Plan and UK Battery Strategy should set out: a) the forecast labour market involved in reaching its targets for UK-supplied batteries b) the forecast training cost for this workforce; and c) how they plan to train and reskill professionals in the automotive sector to support domestic production of electric vehicles, batteries and other processes in the battery supply chain, including through devolution of the requisite training budgets to local areas.

Link to this item · Read this item

19: Ensure adequate funding for local training programmes and make business support conditional on upskilling employees.

Recommendation · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Recommended (the committee's words)
The Government should ensure that mayoral combined authorities or local councils— especially those that govern strategically important sites where gigafactories could be built—have adequate and flexible funding to tailor support local training programmes. Offers of financial support to businesses in the battery supply chain should be conditional on these companies investing in upskilling and reskilling employees from the automotive industry and other sectors.

Link to this item · Read this item

21: Set out how to commercialise new UK battery technologies with competitive advantages domestically.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
The UK has potential competitive advantages in new battery technologies. However, despite excelling in innovation, it struggles to ensure that new technologies developed in the UK are commercialised domestically. The UK Battery Strategy must set out how the Government plans to ensure that new battery technologies, where the UK has a competitive advantage, are commercialised in the UK.

Link to this item · Read this item

23: UK must establish its lithium-ion battery industry before leapfrogging to new technologies.

Conclusion · First Report - Batteries for electric vehicle manufacturing · Addressed to Department for Business and Trade

Concluded (the committee's words)
The UK may not be able to simply leapfrog into new technologies without first establishing itself in the lithium-ion battery industry. That conclusion reinforces the importance of acting at pace now to develop a battery supply chain in the UK.

Link to this item · Read this item

Reports

1 report

Oral evidence sessions

3 sessions

On smaller screens, scroll horizontally to read every column. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.

Date Session and witnesses Source
12 Sep 2023
Oral evidence session
Edmund Ward · Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, Fred Perry · Department for Business and Trade, Ms Nusrat Ghani MP · Department for Business and Trade
View ↗
23 May 2023
Oral evidence session
Andy Palmer, David Wong · Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), Jeff Pratt · UK Battery Industrialisation Centre, Konstanze Scharring · Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT)
View ↗
9 May 2023
Oral evidence session
Alan Hollis · AMTE Power plc, Ian Constance · Advanced Propulsion Centre UK, Jeff Townsend · Critical Minerals Association, Jeremy Wrathall · Cornish Lithium Limited, Paul Lusty · UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre, Simon Moores · Benchmark Mineral Intelligence, Stephen Gifford · The Faraday Institution
View ↗

Who gave evidence

14 witnesses

On smaller screens, scroll horizontally to read every column. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.

WitnessOrganisationSessions
Alan Hollis · Chief Executive AMTE Power plc 1
Andy Palmer Not recorded 1
David Wong · Senior Technology and Innovation Manager Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) 1
Edmund Ward · Deputy Director, Industrial Decarbonisation Department for Energy Security and Net Zero 1
Fred Perry · Director, Advanced Manufacturing Department for Business and Trade 1
Ian Constance · Chief Executive Advanced Propulsion Centre UK 1
Jeff Pratt · Managing Director UK Battery Industrialisation Centre 1
Jeff Townsend · Founder Critical Minerals Association 1
Jeremy Wrathall · Founder and Chief Executive Cornish Lithium Limited 1
Konstanze Scharring · Director of Policy Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) 1
Ms Nusrat Ghani MP · Minister for Industry and Economic Security Department for Business and Trade 1
Paul Lusty · Director UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre 1
Simon Moores · Chief Executive Benchmark Mineral Intelligence 1
Stephen Gifford · Chief Economist The Faraday Institution 1

Correspondence

2 letters

On smaller screens, scroll horizontally to read every column. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.