Recommendation 6

HMRC and the Insolvency Service are not tackling tax evaders or rogue directors sufficiently, particularly for phoenixism. The number of prosecutions resulting from HMRC’s criminal investigations reduced from 749 in 2018–19 to 344 in 2023–24. The previous Public Accounts Committee has raised concerns about fewer prosecutions meaning there is less of a deterrent effect for those inclined to evade tax. We are encouraged that 6 HMRC says it wants to increase the number of prosecutions resulting from its work, and that it has increased the number of positive charging decisions it has recommended to the Crown Prosecution Service. However, we are concerned that HMRC has not issued any penalties under powers to tackle suppliers of sales suppression software it gained in 2022. The Insolvency Service disqualified just 7 directors for phoenixism between 2018–19 and 2023–24. In total it has disqualified 6,274 directors in that time. Both figures are far too low given estimates of the number of fraudulent company registrations (5% to 20% of all company registrations) and the estimated cost to the Exchequer of contrived insolvency (£500 million a year). The Insolvency Service says it has disqualified directors who carried out phoenixism for more severe offences, and it has doubled the average length of disqualification to 10 years. It says it wants to go further both in volume and increasing publicity, particularly around phoenixism, but has not committed to any targets or forecasts. recommendation HMRC and the Insolvency Service should write to the Committee within six months with a plan to bear down on tax evaders and rogue directors who flout insolvency rules. This plan should include details of: a. how both organisations will increase prosecutions and disqualifications; b. how they will better publicise cases of successful prosecutions and disqualifications; and c. how they will report on their performance and ensure they are measuring the deterrent effect of their responsiv