Source · Select Committees · Public Accounts Committee
Recommendation 17
17
Accepted
Limited progress and insufficient data for evaluating other dental recovery plan initiatives
Conclusion
In terms of the other initiatives, NHSE confirmed that it is too early to say whether the uplift to £28 minimum UDA value has had any impact.46 It said that it will only be after the year end that data will be available on the UDA uplift.47 For ‘golden hellos’, as of February 2025 only 39 (less than 20% of the hoped for 240) ‘golden hello’ dentists had been appointed. NHSE acknowledged that this was a “slightly slower start than we had hoped” but felt that a longer time scale will be needed to evaluate whether that initiative has generated benefits.48 No ICB has decided to commission a mobile dental van.49 NHSE has begun publishing data on the NPP, and a programme of evaluation has commenced, but beyond that will need more time to definitively say what impact, if any, the plan has had.50 40 Q 13 41 Q 14 42 C&AG’s Report, para 3.5 43 Q 14 44 Q 14 45 DHSC, Dental patients to benefit from 700,000 extra urgent appointments, published 21 February 2025 46 Q 26 47 Q 14 48 Qq 41–42 49 Q 49 50 Q 73 13
Government Response Summary
The government commits to NHSE carrying out analysis of the New Patient Premium, Golden Hellos, and UDA uplift initiatives, with data collected by July 2025 and a detailed breakdown provided by Autumn 2025. The national mobile dental van program will not be included as it was not implemented.
Government Response
Accepted
HM Government
Accepted
2.1 The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation. Target implementation date: Autumn 2025 2.2 NHSE is carrying out analysis of the main initiatives which were planned to result in additional appointments being delivered: the New Patient Premium, Golden Hellos and the uplift to the minimum Unit of Dental Activity (UDA) rate. The government decided not to implement a national programme of mobile dental vans and so this will not be included in this analysis. The impact of these 3 initiatives will be assessed using changes in activity claims and UDAs delivered. In line with NHSE’s regular data collection process and usual reporting timelines for dental contractors to submit returns, NHSE expects all data for 2024-25 to have been collected by end of July 2025. NHSE will then be in a position to run further analysis and provide a detailed breakdown for each of the initiatives individually. This should be completed by end of August 2025 and NHSE will write to the Committee in the Autumn to set out the results of this analysis. 2.3 In addition to this analysis, NHSE has carried out focus groups with stakeholders to understand their views on the New Patient Premium and will also undertake an evaluation of the Golden Hello scheme, due to be completed and shared with ministers by Summer 2025. This will be published alongside the main evaluation in Autumn 2025. 2.4 The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation. Target implementation date: Autumn 2025 2.5 NHSE will carry out analysis of how many additional appointments were delivered by the 3 main initiatives in the dental recovery plan as set out in response to recommendation 2a. The government decided not to implement a national programme of mobile dental vans and so this will not be included in the analysis. 2.6 The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation. Target implementation date: Autumn 2025 2.7 Due to the two-month window for activity claims to be submitted by dental contractors, the data necessary to provide this confirmation will be available from Summer 2025. Factoring in time for analysis of this data NHSE would expect to be able to report on the impact of the individual initiatives by Autumn 2025.