Source · Select Committees · Public Accounts Committee
Recommendation 10
10
In contrast, the RSPB told us that there had already been a lot of unnecessary...
Conclusion
In contrast, the RSPB told us that there had already been a lot of unnecessary delay to the roll-out of the scheme so far, which added to the urgency of getting the scheme right quickly. It explained that the roll-out of SFI22 needed to make sure it was sending a clear signal as to the direction of travel. The Tenant Farmers Association highlighted that it asked for a delay 12 months ago but no longer thought that now was the right time for it. It instead said it was important that the scheme moved forward and that the Department ensured that there was communication over scheme details, payment rates and how the Department and the Rural Payments Agency, which is responsible for administering payments, are going to deliver the scheme for farmers.22 The Wildlife and Countryside Link, in its written evidence, also told us that, “despite challenges, there must not be a delay in the design, communication and roll-out of Environmental Land Management”. It explained that this was important to minimise the risk that Government will fail to meet its environmental objectives, and also to lessen the risk of disenfranchisement from farmers and land managers that could result from delaying.23
Government Response
Not Addressed
HM Government
Not Addressed
Despite the tight timescales and continuing uncertainty around the launch of SFI22 next year, the stakeholders we heard from were divided on whether a delay to the roll-out and to the reduction in direct payments was necessary. The National Farmers’ Union recommended a delay to ensure that the scheme is ready to work for both farmers and the environment. In its written evidence it said: “The NFU does not believe that a delay of the transition is the solution. A delay would only extend the period of uncertainty, and potentially push the worst impacts of the transition further down the line.” The government wants to deliver a smooth transition for farmers and these views have been fully taken into account.