Source · Select Committees · Public Accounts Committee

Recommendation 6

6 Accepted

We are concerned that the Agency is not doing enough to prevent the illegal export...

Recommendation
We are concerned that the Agency is not doing enough to prevent the illegal export of waste. The Agency estimates that around 14 million tonnes of waste are legitimately exported each year. In the five years to 2020–21, the Agency inspected 1,100 shipping containers per year on average, preventing around 18,000 tonnes of waste from illegal export and saving the economy £1.3 million annually. The Agency believes that most illegally exported waste goes to non-OECD countries where controls on the harms this waste may cause are weaker. The Agency accepts that, despite its efforts, it does not know the total amount of waste that is illegally exported. However, the Environmental Services Association estimates that around 400,000 tonnes of waste are exported illegally each year, costing the economy £42 million. The Agency can do more here – it told us about a record £1.5 million fine it achieved for waste export offences committed by a waste disposal company last year, which was the company’s second offence within two years. In this instance, investigators were able to prevent 16 25-tonne containers from being exported, but another 26 containers had already left port for India or Indonesia. Recommendation: The Agency should write to us within six weeks setting out what actions would be required to enable it to understand the true scale of illegal waste exports and what further action it might take to prevent them.
Government Response Summary
The government agrees and states that the Chief Executive of the Environment Agency sent a response to the committee on November 30th. HMRC is collaborating with the agency to estimate the scale of illegal exports and potential losses.
Government Response Accepted
HM Government Accepted
The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation Recommendation implemented A response has been provided to the Committee by Sir James Bevan, Chief Executive of the Environment Agency, sent to the committee on the 30th of November. HMRC is also collaborating with the agency to produce an estimate of the scale of illegal exports and the potential losses to the exchequer that considers all available data whilst identifying data gaps.